Quantcast
Channel: Newsbreak
Viewing all 8777 articles
Browse latest View live

FALSE: Jovito Salonga's 'letter' to Cory saying Marcos had no ill-gotten wealth

$
0
0

Claim: Former Senate President and Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG) Chairman Jovito Salonga submitted to then-president Corazon Aquino a letter dated August 25, 1986, stating that former president Ferdinand Marcos had no ill-gotten wealth.

The letter said Marcos’ wealth was composed of “divine assets and properties of the Holy Father in heaven” and that the late dictator had transferred the authority over these possessions to a certain “Spiritual Wonder Boy.”

Salonga supposedly found out about this after a “preliminary conference” with the Union Bank of Switzerland, which allegedly showed him Marcos’ 62-page last will and testament as proof that his wealth was “divine, restricted, and not ill-gotten.”

The one-page letter carried the PCGG’s seal and was signed by Salonga, Aquino, and Marcos himself. It also had signatures of prominent world leaders: then-US president Ronald Reagan and Queen Elizabeth II.

The claim is not new. Social media monitoring tool CrowdTangle and reverse image search engines show the earliest available post about the letter was dated October 2015 on Facebook.

Since then, at least 5 websites and 4 Facebook accounts/pages have included the letter in their posts, with the most recent shared in September 2019. The combined Facebook engagements of these posts reached over 3,700 shares, 4,100 reactions, and 590 comments.

The posts that got the most number of engagements are from websites radioblogveritas.blogspot.com, gulongngpaladcirclesoflife.blogspot.com, and Facebook page Alpha Omega World Development Marshall Programme.

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The "signatures" of Jovito Salonga and Corazon Aquino in the letter are different from samples shown in laws they signed. The PCGG also never said Ferdinand Marcos had no ill-gotten wealth and is still chasing traces of the family's stolen funds to this day. 

By August 1986 when Salonga’s alleged letter was dated, the Swiss Executive Council had already frozen Marcos’ bank accounts in Switzerland 4 months prior – or in April that year – after the PCGG requested legal assistance from Swiss authorities. (READ: Recovering Marcos’ ill-gotten wealth: After 30 years, what?)

In 2014, the PCGG said they had recovered all funds from the Marcoses’ known Swiss bank accounts but there may be more left undiscovered.

The PCGG, whose primary mandate is to recover the illicit wealth of the Marcoses, never stopped chasing the family's stolen funds. (READ: At 30: PCGG by the numbers)

The commission was almost abolished under the Duterte administration after the House of Representatives voted in favor of the abolition, but the Senate overrode the decision. Senator Richard Gordon said the PCGG has collected at least P171 billion over the years despite a limited budget. (READ: Senate version wins: PCGG will not be abolished– Pauline Macaraeg/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.


Newsbreak Chats: How gov't is handling the GCTA, BuCor mess

$
0
0

Bookmark this page to watch and join the discussion live on Thursday, September 26, at 4 pm!

MANILA, Philippines – The controversy involving the Good Conduct Time Allowance (GCTA) law has moved its focus from convicted murderer-rapist Antonio Sanchez to the shortcomings of the law itself and corruption inside the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor). 

But the numerous Senate hearings since the issue erupted seemed to veer away from certain government officials, who formerly headed the controversial government agency: Nicanor Faeldon and now-Senator Ronald dela Rosa.  (READ: [EDITORIAL] BuCor Senate hearings: Bakit pinalusot si Bato at Faeldon?

On Thursday, September 26, the Newsbreak team sits down to discuss the way the government is handling the issue, whether they are on the right track, and what else they need to do to full-proof the implementation of the GCTA law. 

How should the accused officials be held accountable? What should the key inclusions in the revised Implementing Rules and Regulations be? Can the BuCor even clean its image? 

Watch the discussion live on Thursday, September 26! – Rappler.com

MORE ON 'NEWSBREAK CHATS' IN 2019

MORE ON 'NEWSBREAK CHATS' IN 2018

FALSE: Bong Go is the 'first Chinese-Filipino who became senator'

$
0
0

FIRST FILIPINO CHINESE SENATOR? President Rodrigo Roa Duterte says in a speech during the Golden Topper Corporate Launch on September 25 that Senator Bong Go is the 'first Chinese-Filipino who became a senator.' Photo by King Rodriguez/Office of the President

Claim: President Rodrigo Duterte said that Senator Bong Go is the first Chinese-Filipino to become senator.

The President made this claim on Wednesday, September 25, at the corporate launch of the real estate development firm Golden Topper Group Incorporated Philippines.

In his speech for the event, Duterte spoke mostly about not employing illegal foreign workers or dabbling in illegal drug trafficking.

At one point during his speech, he called Go, his trusted aide, up on the stage.

Duterte introduced Go as "the first Chinese-Filipino who became a senator."

He continued, "He used to be my aide for 21 years until the Filipino people took notice of him as a handsome Chinese guy from China."

Rating: False

The facts: Go, who became senator for the first time in June, is not the first one of Chinese descent that the Philippines has had.

Sherwin Gatchalian, the son of Chinese businessman William Gatchalian, became senator in 2016 and is still in office.

Former president Benigno "Noynoy" Aquino III, who was a senator from 2007 to 2010, is Chinese through his mother's side of the family, whose surname is Cojuangco.

Alfredo Lim, who was a senator from 2004 to 2007, and Nikki Coseteng, who was a senator from 1992 to 2001, also have Chinese ancestry.

The late Sergio Osmeña, who was a senator from 1922-1934, hailed from a Chinese-Filipino family.

Regardless of race, however, all Philippine senators must be natural born citizens, according to Section 3, Art. VI of the Constitution. (READ: Philippine citizenship: From jus soli to jus sanguinis)

Article IV, Section 1 of the 1987 Constitution describes a natural born citizen as the following:

  • Those who are citizens of the Philippines at the time of the adoption of this Constitution
  • Those whose fathers or mothers are citizens of the Philippines
  • Those born before January 17, 1973, of Filipino mothers, who elect Philippine citizenship upon reaching the age of majority
  • Those who are naturalized in accordance with law

– Rappler.com/Vernise L. Tantuco

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time. 

 

FALSE: Teachers to receive ‘DepEd anniv bonus’ starting November 15

$
0
0

Claim: Public school teachers will receive P3,000 starting November 15, or the “DepEd anniversary bonus.”

Website DepEd Click posted an article on September 17, 2019 listing the bonuses to be received by public school teachers starting November 15 of "every year." A reader emailed the post to Rappler for fact checking.

Along with the anniversary bonus, DepEd Click also said teachers are entitled to a 14th-month pay, a P5,000 cash gift, and productivity enhancement incentive (PEI). The website called it the “official list of the bonuses and incentive for public school teachers.”

As of writing, Deped Click’s post on Facebook got over 2,000 shares, 6,500 reactions, and 361 comments. Social media monitoring tool CrowdTangle also estimated that the link got over 12,585 Facebook engagements from posts shared by private accounts.

Rating: FALSE

The facts:Public school teachers are not entitled to the Department of Education (DepEd) anniversary bonus this year, because it is only given every 5 years. The last time it was given was in 2018.

“It is given only in milestone years – every 5 years. So next anniv bonus will be on 2023,” clarified Annalyn Sevilla, DepEd undersecretary for finance-budget and performance monitoring.

DepEd Click’s post is also not the official list of bonuses to be received by public school teachers in the country because the list did not come from DepEd. 

Sevilla also confirmed to Rappler that the website is not affiliated with the department.

“What is confirmed to be paid on or after November 15 is the year-end bonus (equivalent to one month salary) and P5,000 cash gift. PEI in the amount of P5,000 is to be given not earlier than December 15 of each year, per DBM Circular 2017-4 and EO 201, s. 2016,” added Sevilla.

This is not the first time Rappler has fact checked DepEd Click. Earlier this month, the website also made a claim that there is no pay hike for teachers in proposed 2020 budget, which was misleading. – Pauline Macaraeg/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.

FALSE: Wealth of Marcos family from 'hard work,' and 'not from public funds'

$
0
0

Claim: The Marcos family accumulated their assets through hard work. Their wealth did not come from public funds. 

On September 11, 2019, Facebook user Bren Batongbakal IV posted a long list of historical claims that were supposedly not taught in schools. 

A part of the claim read:

“Yung yaman at mga alahas ng pamilya Marcos ay nanggaling mismo sa kanilang pagsisikap, hindi galing sa kaban ng bayan. (The wealth and jewelry of the  Marcos family came from their hard work, and were not taken from public funds)."

The post went viral gaining 33,129 shares with 22,165 reactions and comments combined. The claim was sent to Rappler's email for a fact check. 

Rating: FALSE

The facts: Total known assets seized from the Marcos family are way above the legitimate income they earned during the time they occupied Malacañang, computed in a 2003 Philippine Supreme Court (SC) ruling at only US$304,372.43. The Marcoses have failed to show proof of other legitimate sources of their wealth, thus the High Court used this to declare the family's Swiss deposits as ill-gotten. 

On July 15, 2003, the SC ruled in favor of the Philippine government in a forfeiture case filed by the Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG) in 1987 against the Marcoses. 

The SC declared the Swiss deposits, which had an aggregate amount of over $658 million as of January 31, 2002, as ill-gotten wealth. The money was held in escrow at the time at the Philippine National Bank (PNB). (READ: FALSE: ‘No proof’ that Marcos couple stole billions from Filipinos). 

The Sandiganbayan also forfeited the third jewelry collection of former first lady Imelda Marcos in January 2014 in favor of the Philippine government. 

Based on the official report of the budget minister then, Ferdinand Marcos earned a total salary of P660,000 from 1966 to 1976, and P800,000 from 1977 to 1984 while he was president. Imelda Marcos accumulated a total of P718,750 from June 1976 to February 22-25, 1986 as then-human settlements minister. Below is the amount of salaries they earned and the sources of income as reflected in the SC decision:

The total accumulated salaries of the Marcos couple while in power was over P2,319,583.33. This amount, when converted based on the dollar-exchange rate during their time, is equivalent to $304,372.43 – lower than the illegal money forfeited from Swiss banks. 

Both of them, according to the court ruling, had reported a total income of over P16 million or US$2,414,484.91 in total income over a period of 20 years from 1965 to 1984.

Below is the breakdown of their other sources of income based on their filed income tax return:

However, the SC said in its July 2003 ruling that only the sum of over $304,000 could be considered as the known lawful income of the Marcos couple since they did not file any Statement of Assets and Liabilities (SAL) which could determine their net worth.

Ferdinand Marcos died on September 8, 1989. 

His wife, Imelda, was initially convicted of two counts of graft in 1993 over anomalous contracts involving a lease between the Light Rail Transit Authority and the Philippine General Hospital Foundation Inc. In 1998, the Supreme Court acquitted her.

Her 2nd conviction was the one handed down on November 9, 2018 and consisted of 7 counts of graft for illegally creating and maintaining private organizations in Switzerland while she held various government positions.

As of 2016, the PCGG was able to recover more than P170-billion worth of ill-gotten wealth of the Marcoses and their cronies. – Glenda Marie Castro/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.   

Senators joke Peralta is next chief justice

$
0
0

THE NEXT CJ? Senators tease Associate Justice Diosdado Peralta that he is the next chief justice. File photo by Darren Langit/Rappler

Senators now call him the chief.

Supreme Court Associate Justice Diosdado Peralta, a chief justice applicant, laughed off on Monday, September 30, the teasing of senators who called him the next chief justice. (READ: How they voted: Meet the chief justice aspirants for 2019)

As he did at the House of Representatives, Peralta represented the judiciary at the Senate to defend its P38.71-billion budget for 2020.

Senator Franklin Drilon repeatedly called Peralta chief.

"May I request for Court Administrator (Midas) Marquez with the guidance of the chief, I mean Justice Peralta, to come up with remedial legislation," Drilon said as he and Senator Sonny Angara discussed with the Justice, possible adjustments in rules to avoid the recycling of seized drugs.

Marquez joined in on the teasing, saying, "with the guidance of the chief your honor," referring to Peralta.

Peralta is the most senior of the 4 chief justice applicants, who include Associate Justice Estela Perlas-Bernabe, Andres Reyes Jr ,and Jose Reyes Jr.

This is the third time that Peralta is applying to be chief justice. Peralta was bypassed for the post when President Rodrigo Duterte picked retired chief justice Teresita Leonardo de Castro, and then retiring chief justice Lucas Bersamin. Peralta was more senior than Bersamin.

"I dropped by to express my support to the Supreme Court family, my Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE) mentor, the next chief justice," said Senator Francis Tolentino who spoke in the budget hearing, only to say he supports the SC.

The Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) will hold its public interviews of the chief justice applicants on Wednesday, October 2.

After Maria Lourdes Sereno was ousted, Peralta was reported to be a front-runner in the race for chief justice, with his ace being no less than then-speaker Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, a staunch ally of President Rodrigo Duterte.

Arroyo appointed Peralta to the SC in 2009, the last full year of her presidency. Their fathers were friends; Peralta was even named after Arroyo’s father, former president Diosdado Macapagal.

Decisions and votes

Peralta has been advocating for reforms in the handling of drugs cases, being the ponente of People vs Lim, where the High Court warned police and prosecutors that a weak drug case would be thrown out. It set a precedent for succeeding acquittals that aimed to prevent planting of evidence by the cops.

People v Lim has since been a hot topic in the judiciary, particularly how it affects the government’s campaign against illegal drugs.

Peralta earlier said “we are failing in drugs cases” due to the sheer volume of cases being filed, overwhelming both prosecutors and courts.  

Peralta penned the controversial ponencia that allowed a hero’s burial for dictator Ferdinand Marcos, triggering nationwide protests. 

Peralta also wrote the ponencia that made the Good Conduct Time Allowance (GCTA) law retroactive.

So far, Peralta has never voted against the President in cases that directly impacted his administration – like the martial law in Mindanao cases – and even those that were of interest to him, like the quo warranto ouster of Sereno.

Key SC decisions from 2006 indicate that Peralta, as well as Andres Reyes Jr, lean towards the executive or politicians. – Rappler.com 

Read more stories on the Supreme Court:

FALSE: Marawi war 'triggered' by 'attempt to serve a warrant of arrest for drug trafficking'

$
0
0

TEDDYBOY LOCSIN. Foreign Secretary Teodoro L Locsin Jr addresses the general debate of the UN General Assembly's 74th session. Photo by Cia Pak/UN Photo

Claim: At the general debate of the 74th United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), Foreign Secretary Teodoro "Teddyboy" Locsin Jr said that the Marawi war, which lasted from May 23 to October 17, 2017, was "triggered" by an attempt to serve an arrest warrant for drug trafficking.

He said: "Terrorism, with its links to drug trafficking and organized crime, is the most pressing threat to us all. The fight to retake the city of Marawi, which left it looking like Swiss cheese, was triggered by an attempt to serve a warrant of arrest for drug trafficking on the leader of an Islamic jihad."

Locsin spoke as the Philippines' representative at the UNGA general debates on Saturday, September 28, New York time (Sunday, September 29, Manila time).

The theme for this year's debate was “Galvanizing multilateral efforts for poverty eradication, quality education, climate action, and inclusion.”

Rating: FALSE

The facts:  The Maute group's involvement in drug trafficking was never mentioned in early statements made by defense and military leaders in explaining why they conducted the operations that triggered the escalation of hostilities in the city. 

The Philippine military had been engaged in clashes with the Abu Sayyaf Group and the Maute Group for months before the Marawi war broke. The Abu Sayyaf has links to ISIS. Its leader, Isnilon Hapilon, based in Basilan in the western part of Mindanao, reportedly brought some of his men to Lanao del Sur in late 2016 to join the Maute Group. [READ: Isnilon Hapilon is target of military operation in Marawi]

On May 23, 2017, fighting triggered by a military surgical strike against "high value targets" belonging to the two groups escalated into a siege of Marawi City. [READ: Maute Group waves ISIS black flag on Marawi streets]

This prompted President Rodrigo Duterte to call in more troops and declare martial law over the entire island of Mindanao. At the time, he cited the "existence of rebellion." [READ: TIMELINE: Marawi clashes prompt martial law in all of Mindanao]

It was later revealed that the Mautes were also involved in drugs. On June 23, 2017, security forces reportedly recovered 11 kilos of suspected drugs from a fallen stronghold of Maute terrorists in Marawi.

In September 2017, President Duterte released a matrix linking the Mautes to the drug trade. At the time, however, Duterte admitted that the government was finding it hard to draw conclusions.

The claim that the seige started because the police went there to serve a warrant of arrest on one of the Mautes, for drugs came from President Duterte himself. In her commentary entitled, "In the name of drugs again," Ellen Tordesillas of Vera Files noted that the President mentioned this in a speech he made before businessmen on October 19, 2017.

Duterte caused dismay among Moro leaders and security experts when he reiterated this again during his 2019 State of the Nation Address. In reference to the siege, he said "drug money killed 175 and wounded [2,101] of my soldiers and policemen in that 5-month battle.”

In that speech, Duterte made no further mention in his SONA of plans to rehabilitate the war-torn city, or of programs to curb terrorism. This is despite the recent emergence of suicide attacks in parts of Mindanao and the threat it presents to the rest of the country. – Rappler.com 

EXPLAINER: Ano ang polio?

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines – Matapos ang 19 taon, idineklara ng Department of Health (DOH) na may polio outbreak sa Pilipinas. 

Ayon sa DOH, isang 3 taong gulang na batang babae mula sa Lanao del Sur at isang 5 taong gulang na batang lalaki mula sa Laguna ang kumpirmadong may polio. Bukod dito, may natagpuan din ang ahensiya na mga "environmental sample" ng poliovirus sa Maynila at Davao. 

Sinasabing mga pangunahing sanhi ng pagbalik ng sakit ang mababang nibel ng pagpapabakuna, ang hindi maagap na pagbabantay sa mga sintomas ng sakit, at ang maruming paligid. 

Ano nga ba ang polio at paano maiiwasan ang pagkalat nito? Panoorin ang video explainer ng Rappler. – Rappler.com

READ: EXPLAINER: What is polio?

Animation by Janina Malinis/Rappler


Garin tries to block Atienza’s speech on Dengvaxia, tetanus vaccines

$
0
0

CLASH. Iloilo 1st District Representative Janette Garin interpellates Buhay Representative Lito Atienza on October 1, 2019. Screenshot from the House of Representatives YouTube account

Things got heated in the House of Representatives when Iloilo 1st District Representative Janette Garin tried to bar Buhay Representative Lito Atienza from completing his privilege speech involving the Dengvaxia controversy and the tetanus vaccine. 

On Tuesday, October 1, Atienza said he wanted to deliver his speech to clear his name after he felt a certain congresswoman – whom he did not name yet – accused him of “sowing fake news” in the House.  

The congressman was alluding to Garin’s interpellation of Bagong Henerasyon Representative Bernadette Herrera Dy on Monday, September 30. Dy had delivered a speech about the importance of vaccination, given the return of polio to the Philippines. During this exchange, Garin said “fake news” about the effects of vaccines eventually led to lower immunization rates in the country.

On Tuesday, Atienza then argued that parents are afraid to vaccinate their kids because of two things: the Tetanus Toxoid vaccine that, he claims, is an abortifacient (this is false) and the aftermath of the Dengvaxia mess. (READ: A year after Dengvaxia: Immunization drops, measles outbreaks soar)

Atienza went on to say that the now-suspended dengue vaccination program that made use of Dengvaxia was allegedly rushed by the Aquino administration in time for the 2016 elections. Garin was the Department of Health (DOH) secretary at this time.

“Now, the lady who stood up yesterday branded my information that I was carrying  into this chamber as nothing but fake news. That is unfair. Coming from a member of Congress, she should have respected my opinion as I would have respected her. But since she branded it as fake news, I’m wiling to prove this in any forum,” said Atienza.  

“If she is able to prove that I have infected this chamber with fake news, I’m willing to be prosecuted and willing to risk my position. But if I’m able to prove in that debate that I’m [correct] – I’m inviting her to join me – she has to answer for the Dengvaxia deaths and the dengue deaths!” said an impassioned Atienza. 

It was at this point when Garin raised a point of order, cutting Atienza’s speech short. 

She questioned why the Buhay congressman was being allowed to speak, when privilege speeches are often delivered on Mondays. 

Deputy Majority Leader Juan Pablo Bondoc then said Atienza’s speech is in order, because Section 102 of the House rules states every lawmaker gets 10 minutes to “raise a question of personal or collective privilege speech” as long as he or she is able to secure permission from the House committee on rules, which oversees plenary proceedings.

This was not enough for Garin, who tried other means to stop Atienza from finishing his speech.

Some 837,000 Filipino gradeschoolers were already vaccinated before Sanofi Pasteur announced in November 2017 that Dengviaxia might lead a person to get severe dengue if he or she had not been infected by the virus before immunization.

In the aftermath of the Dengvaxia scandal, immunization rates across the country decreased. It led to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases like measles and polio.

Garin, ex-president Benigno Aquino III, and other former government officials have since faced multiple complaints filed against them in relation to the Dengvaxia mess.

The standoff

After initially cutting off Atienza’s speech on Tuesday, Garin questioned the presence of a quorum in the plenary and moved for a roll call to be called.

When a House member questions the quorum, the attendance of legislators has to be checked by the secretariat. 

“Mister Speaker, with the answer of the Majority [Floor] Leader, allow me to enlighten him that our rules say that no matter can be discussed without quorum. I therefore move to call the roll,” said Garin.

Deputy Speaker Michael Romero, who was presiding over the session, immediately suspended the session.

Atienza then spoke up, and began saying, “We can call the roll a million times…”

But this struck a chord with Garin, who then tried to make a motion ordering the House secretary-general to remove Atienza from the plenary hall. 

“Mister Speaker, may I request the secretary-general to bring the honorable colleague out of this floor? We are not in session and he keeps on talking,” said the visibly irked legislator. 

Garin’s motion, however, was not acted upon by the plenary. When the session resumed, the roll call was called and 209 lawmakers were recorded as present.  

But Garin still did not give up. She continued questioning why the plenary was allowing Atienza to speak. Bondoc simply repeated the provisions of Section 102 of the House rules. 

“Debate will never be curtailed in the House of Representatives,” Bondoc told Garin. 

Session was again suspended for 16 minutes. Bondoc and other legislators were then seen in a huddle with Garin. 

The interpellation

When session was resumed, Garin was finally able to interpellate Atienza. 

The medical doctor-turned-congresswoman then dedicated much of the exchange correcting Atienza’s false claim that the tetanus vaccine is an abortaficient. But she also addressed Atienza’s criticisms on the Dengvaxia vaccine.

“The challenge for me to resign, if indeed Dengvaxia causes deaths, surely, Mister Speaker, I welcome and accept that. I've been saying that several times: dengue vaccines do not cause deaths,” said Garin. 

 “Vaccination is not just our children’s obligation. It is the right of every people. It is an obligation of our government,” she added. 

At the end of their exchange, Atienza still took a swipe at Garin.

“I will leave the rostrum with one message. There are 3 things that cannot be hidden: The moon, the sun, and the truth,” said Atienza. 

The DOH has not yet confirmed whether Dengvaxia caused any deaths. But the DOH has already banned the vaccine in the country after the controversy erupted. – Rappler.com

FALSE: Bamboo Mañalac ‘dies in car crash in Quezon’

$
0
0

Claim:Rock band singer Bamboo Mañalac died in a car collision in Quezon province.

In an undated video posted by websites thetrue.i-witnesstv.com and h0tbuzz.phtrends.info, a purported ABS-CBN news headline read, "BAMBOO MANALAC Patay matapos madamay sa karambola ng mga sasakyan sa Quezon (JUST IN: Bamboo Manalac dies after being involved in a car crash in Quezon).” 

The thumbnail in the video shows an image of the singer with a text overlay that reads: “RIP Bamboo Manalac 1976 – 2019.” 

When the video is clicked, it redirects to websites latestnewstv.info and nationalistanews.info. On these websites, the original news report from ABS-CBN can be found, but the video caption still retained the claim. 

A warning message in the video says that it must be shared first before viewers can watch it fully. 

The websites news.kanyeisinthelighthouse.com and ang.balitangtv.info have also posted the claim. 

A reader emailed the claim to Rappler for fact checking. Facebook's fact checking tool Claim Check showed that the post was first shared on the platform on September 27. It has been posted 134 times on Facebook, accumulating total reactions, comments, and shares of over 6,000. 

Rating: FALSE

The facts: Mañalac is still alive. No report from any credible news site was released about the car accident he was supposedly in. 

The singer’s latest social media activities show that he is preparing for an upcoming concert tour in Australia from October 11 to 13. There is an Instagram post dated September 30 of a poster for his concert. 

The video used in the claim is an ABS-CBN News report uploaded to its official YouTube channel on February 16, 2019. It contained a 51-second flash report about the collision of bus, van, and AUV in Lopez, Quezon which left 3 dead and 7 injured. Mañalac was not mentioned in this video.

The official website of music TV channel MYX also posted an article saying that Mañalac was a victim of a death hoax.

The website news.kanyeisinthelighthouse.com has been previously fact-checked for posting a death hoax of late veteran actor Eddie Garcia before he passed away. 

Some celebrities have also fallen victims to this kind of false claim, including Gary Valenciano and John Lloyd Cruz.

The websites, which posted the claim, have a disclaimer that says, “This site does not claim any ownership or copyright on all the audio or videos shared.” The site latestnewstv.info also mentioned a list of their unverified sources which are Trending Portalz, Manila Portalz, Trendz, and Filipino Balita Portaz. – Glenda Marie Castro/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.

'Spectacle of a grand cover-up': Senate hearing bares how 'ninja cops' remain in service

$
0
0

INTERVENTION? Philippines' top cop General Oscar Albayalde is tagged in the 2013 case involving his former men at the Pampanga police. Photo by Angie de Silva/Rappler

MANILA, Philippines (UPDATED) – The marathon hearings of the Senate blue ribbon committee led to the discussion of something close to the heart of the Duterte administration: the war on drugs.

After 7 hearings, the issues have evolved from a wide range of topics – from the loopholes in the "good conduct time allowance (GCTA) law, prison reform, the drug kingpins of the New Bilibid Prison, and now the involvement of "ninja cops" in illegal drugs.

But what raised eyebrows on Tuesday, October 1, was the alleged intervention of Philippine National Police chief General Oscar Albayalde in what seemed to be a "grand cover-up" – as the senators believed – to protect his underlings from dismissal from service over a 2013 case.

Roughly a month before Albayalde's retirement on November 7, the 2013 incident seemed to haunt the country's top cop. What happened?

Timeline

November 29, 2013

10 am – Twelve Pampanga cops conduct a buy-bust operation in Mexico, Pampanga which led to the recovery of 36.68 kilos of metamphetamine hydrochloride (shabu) and a P100,000 marked money. The team is headed by ex-Pampanga anti-illegal drug operations task group chief Joven de Guzman Jr, along with 11 others:

  • Senior Police Officer 1 Jules Maniago
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Donald Roque
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Bayas Santos
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Rommel Vital
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Alcindor Tinio
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Dante Dizon
  • Senior Police Officer 1 Eligio Valeroso
  • Police Officer 3 Dindo Dizon
  • Police Officer 3 Gilbert de Vera
  • Police Officer 3 Romeo Guerrero
  • Police Officer 2 Anthony Lacsamana

The group is supposed to go after the Chinese drug lord Johnson Lee, but instead arrest another suspected drug dealer Ding Wenkun.

During this time, Albayalde was the acting police chief of Pampanga.

The team conducts a buy-bust operation leading to the arrest of a drug suspect named Johnson Lee. But according to Magalong, the cops were bribed by Lee with P50 million to let him go and instead arrest a fall guy identified as Ding Wenkun.

Cops also supposedly seized 200 kilograms of shabu, but only declared the seizure of 38 kg.

4:30 pm – The time that the cops claim to have only begun with the buy-bust operation. This is the only time that Albayalde was supposedly informed about the operation.

Baloyo tell senators in the Senate’s joint probe on October 1, 2019, that he did not see it fit to tell Albayalde ahead of the big operation because he was not “sure” it was a hit.

Because of the discrepancy, senators suspect that the time between the actual time and the bogus time was spent by cops to mount a coverup.

November 30, 2013
Cops submit 38 kilograms of shabu as evidence in the afternoon. That the processing took a day violated the rules of handling evidence. Cops are required to process the illegal drugs immediately.

They also fail to include a Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) agent and a barangay official in the operation.

February 2014
Major General Benjamin Magalong leads the CIDG at this time. He holds a briefing on the “agaw-bato” (keeping of drugs) scheme of cops before then-police chief General Alan Purisima.

Purisima, according to Magalong, raised a tip he had received that a bunch of intelligence officers in Pampanga suddenly were able to afford buying SUV for themselves, and that it might have had something to do with the illegal practice.

Benjie, imbestigahan mo nga ito, dahil just recently, nagkaroon ng operation itong mga bata diyan sa Pampanga. Meron silang nakuhang mga 30-plus na kilos na shabu pero bigla silang nagkaroon ng magagandang sasakyan, sabay-sabay,” Magalong recalls Purisima telling him then during the Senate hearing on October 1, 2019.

(Benjie, could you investigate this? It’s because just recently, there was an operation by these young cops in Pampanga and they seized 30 plus kilos of shabu, but suddenly they were able to buy good cars, all at the same time.)

Magalong begins his investigation immediately.

March 3, 2014 

The 13 cops, including then-Pampanga intelligence branch head Rodney Balayo, are preventively suspended for not following the standard procedure during the November 2013 buy-bust operation:

  • The certification of seized evidence was signed the following day
  • Confiscated items were not photographed with the arrested suspects
  • Photos of the barangay official, media, and Department of Justice representatives who allegedly witnessed the confiscation were "taken elsewhere"
  • The cops did not request for the presence of the Scene of the Crime Operatives
  • The inventory of the seized drugs was not done where the buy-bust happened

March 11, 2014
The 13 cops are charged for violating Section 27 of the Dangerous Drugs Act, or mishandling of drug-related evidence.

The offense merits life imprisonment and a fine between P500,000 and P10 million.

March 15, 2014
Albayalde is sacked from his post by then-Central Luzon police chief Brigadier General Raul Petrasanta in line with “command responsibility.”

““[It is] due to [Albayalde’s] failure to take corrective action at his level despite the chance given to him to do so,” Petrasanta is reported as saying by the Philippine Daily Inquirer.

November 14, 2014

Then-Central Luzon police director Raul Petrasanta orders the maximum penalty of dismissal from service for the 13 cops.

March 2, 2016
After over a year, the team finally receives the dismissal order.

They are given 12 days to contest the decision of the regional and national headquarters.

March 14, 2016
The cops file a motion for reconsideration to appeal the dismissal order. It would take over a year for the police to resolve this motion.

May 30, 2016
Then Brigadier General Aaron Aquino assumes his post as Central Luzon chief, replacing retiring Brigadier General Rudy Lacadin.

July 4, 2016
Albayalde assumes office as the chief of the National Capital Region Police Office (NCRPO).

NINJA COP? At the hearing, Lt Col Raymund Baloyo IV says he was at the 2013 buy-bust operation, and that 2 security guards were threatening their group that's why they had to do the inventory of the drugs elsewhere. Photo by Angie de Silva/Rappler

Between July and November, 2016 

At the October 1 hearing, Magalong urges Aquino to "tell the truth" when asked if anyone had called the latter in relation to the ninja cops' case. Aquino says that in late 2016, Albayalde called him to ask about the case of the 13 policemen.

"Sinabi niya sa akin, 'Sir, for the meantime, baka puwedeng ipa-review muna 'yan, kasi gusto kong malaman kung ano talaga ang mangyayari sa result ng investigation na iyan…Kasi, Sir, mga tao ko 'yan,'" Aquino recalled Albayalde telling him.

(He told me, 'Sir, for the meantime, maybe you can have that reviewed, because I want to know what will happen to the result of that investigation. Because, Sir, those are my people.')

Albayalde admitted on Tuesday, October 1, that the call indeed happened, but denied trying to influence Aquino: "Yes, I asked for the status – only the status. I could not possibly influence an RD or an upperclass…It's normal but never in one time did I ask for any favor. I was asking for the status."

Magalong told senators on Tuesday that Aquino "did not implement the order" pending the review of the case, as a result of the call, and assigned the erring cops to Mindanao as punishment.

June 2017
According to PNP Drug Enforcement Group chief Brigadier General Albert Ferro, the criminal drugs case against the 13 cops were dismissed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) during this month.

Before rising as DEG chief, Ferro was Magalong’s investigator on top of the 13 cops’ case.

During the Senate hearing on October 1, 2019, Senator Richard Gordon corrects Ferro, saying that the case has not been dismissed but has actually been forwarded to Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra’s office for review. Guevarra says he has delegated the case to an undersecretary.

September 1, 2017
Brigadier General Amador Corpus replaces retiring Aaron Aquino as Central Luzon police chief.

September 12, 2017
Aquino replaces Isidro Lapeña as PDEA chief.

October 17, 2017
Just a month heading the regional office, Corpus issues a resolution deciding on the fate of the 13 ninja cops who filed for a motion for reconsideration. Corpus modifies the penalty from dismissal from service to a "one-rank demotion" instead.

Corpus defended the decision on the October 1, 2019 hearing, saying that the legal officer recommended it. He said that there are two aggravating circumstances (taking advantage of length of service and employment of fraudulent means to commit the offense) and a mitigating circumstance (numerous awards and commendations) which led to a "net of one aggravating circumstance."

As Corpus justified it, Senate Minority Leader Franklin Drilon said: "As an ordinary citizen and a lawyer, I could not understand why a penalty of dismissal was lowered to a penalty of demotion. Why you made that judgment, may tumawag po ba sa inyo na ibaba ang penalty na 'to (Did somebody call you to lower the penalty)?"

Corpus, who is now heading the CIDG, evaded the question by answering that the facts presented by Magalong during Tuesday's hearing – despite being corroborated by PNP documents – were "distorted."

April 19, 2018
Albayalde replaces General Ronald dela Rosa as chief of the PNP.

He was chosen by Duterte for his reputation as a disciplinarian, frequently landing in the evening news for riding his motorcycle at night and sacking sleeping cops on the spot.

“Albayalde is the man for you. So the stricter the better," Duterte recounts, telling top police officials when he was deciding on Dela Rosa’s successor.

May 14, 2019
Benjamin Magalong is proclaimed the next Baguio City mayor on his first try into politics, defeating PDP-Laban backed Edison Bilog, who never lost an election since 1990.

November 20, 2018
Corpus is promoted to head the CIDG. The vacancy he leaves behind in Central Luzon is filled by former Manila Police District chief Brigadier General Joel Coronel.

September 16, 2019
During a Senate hearing for PDEA’s 2020 budget, Aaron Aquino raises to senators about drug recycling still being “rampant” in the PNP.

“I received some information from assets, from other law enforcement agencies themselves…Hearing these reports, it will just show that there's still recycling of drugs. I guess it's still rampant," Aquino says.

He adds: “When they seize drugs, maybe half of that wll be surrendered. Or they will make it appear that the amount of seized drugs is less. While all the other ones are being kept for other future operations, or worse, [are sold]," Aquino added.

The announcement makes waves in the media, shocking even the PNP itself.

September 19, 2019
The Senate committee on justice and human rights, and the Senate blue ribbon committee hold an executive session – with Magalong – on the practice of drug recycling.

The senators were originally probing the controversial Good Conduct Time Allowance law, but their probe segues to the PNP after witnesses bare the continuous illegal drug operations inside the New Bilibid Prison, even its hospital.

It is in this session that Magalong presents the 2013 Pampanga operation as the chief example of a sting executed by “ninja cops” who were left to continue in the police service by top police officials.

Some time between September 20 and September 30
Magalong and Aquino meet with President Rodrigo Duterte and Senator Bong Go about the “ninja cops” issue at the Manila Hotel.

During the meeting, Magalong remembers Aquino telling the President that Albayalde had called him when they were regional directors “not to implement” the dismissal order for the 13 cops.

In the same time period, Albayalde meets with Duterte in Malacañang to provide an update on the anti-drug campaign and clears his name after the controversy is raised in the Senate.

Albayalde tells reporters later that Duterte would tune in to the Senate hearing on October 1. 

October 1, 2019
12 pm – In the continuation of the joint Senate probe into the GCTA controversy, Magalong repeats his testimony from the September 19 executive session.

Magalong then pushes Aquino to reveal to the Senate and the public what he earlier said during earlier meetings.

"Sabihin mo kung anong sinabi mo sa akin. Sinong kumausap sa 'yo (Tell them what you told me. Who talked to you)?" Magalong told Aquino during the hearing.

Aquino then reveals that Albayalde called him back in 2016 to “review” the dismissal order against the 13 cops, explaining that they were his people.

3:30 pm – In an ambush interview on October 1, 2019, Aquino says Albayalde only told him to “review” the dismissal order, and that the police chief did not pressure him not to implement it. In a separate ambush interview, Magalong said, “I am not lying.”

Albayalde has denied that he “influenced” Aquino in any way, pointing the finger back at Magalong and telling him that he instead as former CIDG chief could have ended the practice of recycling illegal drugs.

8:30 pm – President Rodrigo Duterte holds a press briefing before leaving for Russia for his second visit as head of state. He says he would decide on Albayalde’s fate after Interior Secretry Eduardo Año finishes his probe into the mess.

"The most proper thing to do, which is in line with procedural due process, is to wait for the closure of the investigation by the Senate," Duterte said.

He continues: ”When it is forwarded to me since the police is under the Department of the Interior and Local Government, it's a bureau under Secretary Año, I will forward it to him, give him a specific period to complete his investigation.”


'Grand cover-up' 

As policemen cried for due process, senators believed that the rogue cops actually did not follow it in the 2013 incident.

The senators grilled the police officers why it took them too long to send the copy of the dismissal order for the rogue cops, let alone implement it.

"Masakit pakinggan 'yung hearing natin ngayon, kasi I think it is an embarrassment of due process for the PNP…Pero hanggang ngayon, isa ako with you, Mr Chair, na hindi pa rin maintindihan why it took so long to implement a decision na PNP na mismo ang nagbuo at based on PNP processes," Senator Risa Hontiveros said in a manifestation.

(It hurts to listen to our hearing now because it's an embarrassment of due process for the PNP. But until now, I am with you on this Mr Chair, that I still could not understand why it took so long to implement a decision that the PNP had crafted and was based on PNP processes.)

Senate President Vicente Sotto III, meanwhile, took his thoughts to Twitter as the hearing was ongoing: "We are now witnessing the spectacle of a grand cover-up!"

When Albayalde's 2016 call to Aquino was established, Senator Richard Gordon, the Senate blue ribbon committee chairman, exploded without naming names.

"Why are you trying to get the people off the hook? Are you the mafia or the PNP? Before you can be merciful, you must be just!" the blue ribbon panel head said.

Gordon also slammed Baloyo's current position as the deputy officer-in-charge for Tagaytay, calling it a "promotion" even if the latter was demoted in rank.

In a media interview, Gordon said that trust in Albayalde now has "cracks" because of the ghosts of his past. The senator likened Albayade's situation to Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo, who wrote to the Board of Pardons and Parole about the bid of his ex-client rapist and murder convict Antonio Sanchez for clemency.

"Wala naman akong nakuhang ebidensya na except for 'yung tinawagan 'nya [si Aquino]. If something is under investigation, you don't call somebody. Parang 'yung Panelo 'di ba," Gordon told reporters.

(I was not able to get evidence except for the fact that he called Aquino. If something is under investigation, you don't call somebody. It's like the case of Panelo.)

The issue resurfaced when Magalong bared the names of the cops involved in "drug recycling" to the Senate in a September 19 executive session. A few days later, the Senate authorized Gordon's committee to make the information public.

Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra pledged to complete the automatic review of the dismissed criminal case filed against the ninja cops within a month.

As for Albayalde, President Rodrigo Duterte said that he will decide on the top cop's fate after the Senate wraps up its probe and after Interior Secretary Eduardo Año finishes his own investigation.

Will Albayalde survive this controversy before he retires? – Rappler.com

READ related stories:

FAST FACTS: Things to know about Star City

$
0
0

Photo Courtesy of Shutterstock

MANILA, Philippines – The seemingly endless season of fun in Star City has been devoured by a fire that struck midnight of Wednesday, October 2.

A huge fire engulfed the popular amusement park located at the reclaimed area of the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP) complex in Pasay City. (READ: LOOK: Fire guts Star City complex in Pasay City

From its giant ferris wheel to signature roller coaster, the amusement park will remain for many as one of their most visited fun places. (READ: 'It's our happy place': Netizens recall favorite memories of Star City)

What should you know about the popular amusement park in Pasay? 

From carnaval to amusement park 

Star City is owned by Star Parks Corporation (SPC), a subsidiary of Elizalde Holdings Corporation (EHC). The owner of SPC and EHC was Spanish-Filipino businessman Fred Elizalde, the husband of the Philippines’ first prima ballerina Lisa Macuja Elizalde. Lisa’s father, Cesar Macuja, worked for Elizalde as president of SPC. 

Before its inception in 1991, the amusement park used to be a carnaval. It was originally part of the Toy and Gift Fair, an annual Christmas trade fair under Philippine International Corporation (Philcite), one of the companies also owned by Elizalde. 

Since then, it evolved into being a popular tourist destination with more than 30 rides for all ages. 

Giant roller coaster, extreme rides

In 2012, it opened the Giant Star Wheel to the public, which they claimed to be the highest ferris wheel in the country before the Sky Eye in Tagaytay challenged it.

It stood at 62.5 meters tall, a height equivalent to a 20-22-story building. It also had 32 air-conditioned gondolas, each with a capacity of 6 persons.  

Star City also claimed the Star Flyer as the country's only inverted roller coaster. 

It also took pride with its Snow World, which was said to offer the longest ice slide in the country. Cebu matched this attraction when it opened its indoor theme park, Snow World Cebu, in 2018. 

Based on a list of rides in its official website, it operated 31 rides and attractions.

Past incidents 

This is not the first time that the amusement park faced a major challenge. Several past incidents had cast doubt on its claim that it was a "happy place to be." 

In September 2006, a 13-year-old girl fell from the Wild River ride, now called the Jungle Splash. This led to a proposal to create an Amusement Park Safety Board that seeks to regulate operations of theme parks and carnivals in the country.

In February 2009, a 39-year-old man from Binangonan, Rizal fell from the 65-foot Starflyer. 

In July 2018, a man fell from the top of the Giant Star Wheel Ride. According to police reports, the panel in the gondola where the victim probably jumped was dismantled. – Rappler.com

Chinese vessels in Philippine waters: Who’s keeping score?

$
0
0

BRP SIERRA MADRE. This aerial photo taken from a military aircraft shows the Sierra Madre ship of the Philippine Navy anchored near Ayungin Shoal (Second Thomas Shoal) with Philippine soldiers onboard to secure the perimeter in the Spratly Islands, on May 11, 2015. File photo by Ritchie Tongo/AFP

When Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana faced the Senate budget panel on Monday, September 30, Senator Panfilo Lacson asked him whether the defense establishment had a “counterstrategy” to China’s “cabbage strategy” of swarming the Philippine outposts in the West Philippine Sea with different kinds of vessels to make access difficult, if not impossible, for Filipinos.

“Are we encountering problems in our resupply?” Lacson asked, pertaining to whether the Philippine Navy is able to bring food, water, and other necessities to the marines stationed among the 9 Philippine-held islands and reefs in the Spratlys – the Kalayaan Island Group.

Lorenzana said there was "no problem."

"I think before the President took over in June 2016, mayroong problemang ganoon (there was such a problem). But after that, our resupply can go there unimpeded by the Chinese Coast Guard or the Chinese PLA-Navy,” the defense chief told Lacson and the other senators on the panel.

But, actually, there was – is– a problem.

Last May 14, a China Coast Guard (CCG) ship with bow number 3305 blocked the route of 3 Philippine civilian vessels on a resupply mission to the grounded ship BRP Sierra Madre on Ayungin (Second Thomas) Shoal, according to a report by the Department of National Defense (DND) itself.

In fact, China “regularly deploys at least one CCG vessel perceived to be monitoring the activities” around Ayungin Shoal, “including the arrival of Filipino fishing boats as well as the Rotation and Reprovision mission of the Philippine Navy,” said the same report, submitted on September 13 to Bayan Muna Representative Carlos Zarate. The representative had requested for a definitive account from the DND, following piecemeal revelations about intrusions of Chinese vessels in Philippine waters.

The Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) of the Washington-based think tank Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) corroborated this in a separate report published on September 26.

"Far from being unusual, the [CCG ship] 3305’s deployment around Second Thomas (Ayungin Shoal) was part of a regular pattern of near-constant CCG patrols near the [BRP] Sierra Madre,” the AMTI report said.

Satellite tracking of two other CCG ships showed their paths criss-crossing Ayungin Shoal and brushing by BRP Sierra Madre several times in July and August.

A detail of the Philippine marines is stationed in the World War II-era ship that the Navy deliberately grounded in 1999 to guard Ayungin Shoal after China occupied Mischief Reef, which lies 20 nautical miles away.

During Monday’s budget hearing for the DND, Lorenzana told the Senate panel that a CCG ship was yet again spotted “4 to 5 nautical miles” from Ayungin Shoal, according to a report Lorenzana said he received just the day before.

There was no surprise from the panel, because the China Coast Guard has become a constant presence near Ayungin Shoal and in other parts of the West Philippine Sea, like Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal.

'Liaoning' or not

There did not appear to be a “counterstrategy” to speak of, so the conversation between the senators and the security officials moved on to monitoring and protesting Chinese incursions in Philippine waters.

Chinese coast guard and fishing vessels have been loitering in the West Philippine Sea since the Panatag Shoal standoff in 2012. What grabbed Filipinos’ attention in July was news of a Chinese warship passing through Sibutu Strait in the waters of Tawi-Tawi province.

On July 19, Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio told a forum of students at the University of the Philippines Diliman that he had it on good authority that the Chinese naval aircraft carrier Liaoning had traversed Philippine territorial waters quite recently.

Lorenzana denied it at the time, saying there was no such report from the marines, and that there was such a thing as “innocent passage” of foreign vessels afforded by international maritime law.

A week later, however, the defense chief revealed that 4 Chinese warships had, in fact, passed Sibutu Strait since February, but none of them was an aircraft carrier.

Liaoning or not, Lorenzana’s revelation raised questions about the Philippines’ capability to safeguard its maritime domain, especially because he said the Chinese Navy should have given prior notice of their passage.

Then the plot thickened. The Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) units in western Mindanao and Palawan started releasing more reports of Chinese warships passing Philippine territorial waters.

By mid-August, at least 13 instances of such incursions had been reported by Lorezana and the military.

The question then became whether China had violated Philippine sovereignty with those intrusions, or if they qualified as “innocent passage.”

The reports appeared to have caught the government by surprise, and President Rodrigo Duterte even ordered foreign vessels to seek permission before entering Philippine waters or else be driven out by the Philippine Navy.

However, the September 13 DND report revealed precise information on Chinese warship incursions, complete with the ships’ class and bow numbers, and the dates they were spotted by Philippine forces.

The earliest sighting in 2019 was on February 7.

It even stated that the Liaoning did pass Sibutu Strait in Tawi-Tawi and Balabac Strait in Palawan on June 17, just as Carpio had said.

If the military was able to keep precise records of these Chinese naval incursions, at what point was the information given to Lorenzana? Why did he deny Carpio’s revelation at first? Why was the information made public in tranches when a running record existed all along? Would Lorenzana or the military have revealed any of these to the public at all if Carpio had never brought them up in the first place?

The same DND report said 63 Chinese warships were “observed in the West Philippine Sea and other parts of the South China Sea” in 2018.

No one sounded the alarm then.

SECURITY OFFICIALS. Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana (left) and AFP chief Lieutenant General Noel Clement (right) at the Senate hearing on the proposed 2020 budget of the Department of National Defense and its attached agencies. September 30, 2019. Photo by Angie de Silva/Rappler

Diplomatic protests

Since the start of the Duterte administration, the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) has filed “more or less 60” notes verbale protesting China’s activities in Philippine waters, Foreign Secretary Teodoro Locsin Jr told a budget panel of the House of Representatives on September 4.

Following the advice of maritime law experts like Carpio, Locsin said he had filed 24 “diplomatic protests” since he took over the DFA in October 2018.

Diplomatic protests keep the Philippines’ lawful claims over the West Philippine Sea alive despite China’s incursions, Carpio and other experts have said. Not doing so, on the other hand, could be interpreted as an abandonment of those claims.

Wary of media reports, Locsin has said he only orders the filing of diplomatic protests upon the recommendation of the DND or of the military.

Past midnight on Wednesday, October 2, Locsin tweeted an order to the DFA to “fire off” a diplomatic protest against China over a news report that AFP Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Noel Clement had told the Senate budget panel on Monday about the presence of Chinese vessels near Ayungin Shoal.

It was Lorenzana, not Clement, who told the Senate panel about the latest CCG incursion near Ayungin Shoal.

Clement was asked by reporters after the hearing to give more details about the incursion Lorenzana had talked about, and he said: "May mga namo-monitor but I don’t know the exact numbers as of this time….Hindi kasi regular 'yung numbers. So minsan may nagpapakita isa o dalawa, and a lot of them are actually just fishing boats so I cannot give you the exact details kung ilan talaga 'yung mga pumapasok dun sa area.”

(There are those that are monitored but I don’t know the exact numbers as of this time…. Because the numbers are not regular. So sometimes one or two are spotted, and a lot of them are actually just fishing boats so I cannot give you the exact details of how many really enter the area.)

The DND report submitted to Zarate did say that China uses fishing boats as maritime militias, or paramilitary forces to multiply its presence in the West Philippine Sea. There were 322 such vessels spotted in the first half of 2019.

Clement was further asked whether the information on the latest incursion had been handed over to the DFA.

"Yes. Through the Task Force West Philippine Sea kasi sila ang nagko-collate ng lahat ng (because they are the ones who collate all the) information and they’re the ones who officially communicate this to DFA for the filing of diplomatic protest,” the military chief answered.

During the budget hearing, senators asked Lorenzana to explain the protocol when foreign warships are spotted in Philippine waters.

"Information has to be submitted first to Task Force West Philippine Sea, which is under Malacañang, then that task force under General [Hermogenes] Esperon [Jr], the National Security Adviser, will submit it to the DFA for diplomatic protest,” Lorenzana replied.

However, based on Locsin’s tweet, it was the media report on Clement’s statement on the Chinese incursion that triggered the “firing off” of a diplomatic protest.

If the information had been relayed to the DFA through the task force under Esperon as Clement said, then how come Locsin’s order appeared to have been triggered by a media report quoting Clement?

Did he information not reach Locsin through the official channel described by Lorenzana and Clement?

And what exactly did Locsin or the DFA protest? The CCG ship's presence near Ayungin, according to Lorenzana, or the uncertain number of vessels, according to Clement?

The report on the Chinese presence near Ayungin Shoal came to Lorenzana on Sunday, September 29. The Senate was told about it on September 30. Locsin ordered the DFA on Twitter to file a diplomatic protest as he was headed to Russia with the President at around midnight on Wednesday, October 2.

As Chinese vessels of all sorts come and go through Philippine waters, who exactly is keeping count, and who is telling whom what?

It would be good to know. – Rappler.com

PMA’s record of hazing deaths

$
0
0

COURAGE, INTEGRITY, LOYALTY. Cadets at the Philippine Military Academy in Baguio City are now honor-bound to tell if they have experienced or perpetrated hazing. Photo by Mau Victa/Rappler

MANILA, Philippines – For police chief General Oscar Albayalde, it should be clear to everyone that he would never have tried to intimidate anti-drug chief Director General Aaron Aquino into flouting the law when they were regional police chiefs in 2016, because Aquino was his upperclassman at the Philippine Military Academy (PMA).

Albayalde, of PMA Class 1986, had called up Aquino of PMA Class 1985, to check on the “status” of cases involving 13 cops who were under him when he was Pampanga police chief in 2013.

The 13 cops were accused of pilfering a big portion of a stash of crystal meth they recovered from an anti-drug raid, and they were up for dismissal, but it appears Albayalde, as Metro Manila police chief in 2016, tried to intervene in their favor by asking Aquino, who was then on top of the case as Central Luzon police chief, to hold off.

Of course not, said Albayalde. “I could not possibly influence an RD (regional director) or an upperclass.”

As to why he took an interest in the 13 cops’ fate, Albayalde told Aquino it was because they were his men.

Albayalde’s alibis were self-explanatory in the military culture.

Loyalty as mortar

The third and last word in the PMA’s motto is loyalty. It’s the mortar that holds the military together, that turns a pile of bricks into a formidable wall.

In the tradition of prestigious, exclusive organizations like fraternities and military academies, loyalty is forged through shared hardship upon entry into the group: initiation rites. The overzealous take it further by inflicting physical harm to try the initiate: hazing.

“We all went through this,” Senator Panfilo Lacson of PMA Class of 1971 said in a hall full of active and former military officers during the budget hearing for the Department of National Defense (DND) on Monday, September 30.

The matter of PMA Cadet 4th Class Darwin Dormitorio’s death caused by his fellow cadets’ brutality was the last item to be brought up in the hearing that also tackled funding issues, Chinese spying, and territorial incursions, and the aftermath of terrorism in Marawi City.

Clearly, hazing was the most difficult and sensitive item on the agenda because, as Lacson himself said, it hit home.

On the flipside of the PMA’s long and proud history of churning out military and police generals is a list of cadets who died as the result of hazing, or the culture of torturous loyalty that deadens upperclassmen’s hearts to the plight of plebes too eager to prove themselves worthy, or else too afraid of the price of being judged disloyal should they “squeal” on their taskmasters.

1978: Manuel Salas

Four days before the end of their plebe year, on February 13, 1978, the Bravo Company lay on their backs as their upperclassmen dropped shot puts – heavy metal balls – onto their bare stomachs.

One of the plebes, Cadet 4th Class Manuel Salas, was killed. Another one hemorrhaged and almost died: Alan Purisima, who went on to become chief of the Philippine National Police from December 2012 to February 2015.

2000: Ace Bernabe Ekid

Cadet 4th Class Ace Bernabe Ekid was on his second try joining the academy after having taken a yearlong sick leave when he collapsed during war games at the Philippine Marines base in Ternate, Cavite, in June 2000.

A medic was able to bring Ekid back to consciousness, but the 21-year-old plebe was delirious and incoherent, the Philippine Star reported. Then moments later, he started convulsing and was rushed to a hospital where he died just over an hour later.

Although the PMA after an investigation ruled out hazing as the cause of Ekid’s death, his family and friends insisted he had been singled out for hazing by some upperclassmen because he was good-looking and from a wealthy family.

Ekid’s official cause of death was heatstroke.

2001: Edward Domingo and Monico de Guzman

On March 10, 2001, 23-year-old Cadet 4th Class Edward Domingo was beaten up by several 2nd Class cadets in their dormitory as an initiation rite of passage to his second year in the academy.

Domingo was reportedly hit eight times with a pipe on his buttocks and then punched many times on his abdomen until he collapsed. He then died of a “cardio-respiratory attack” at the PMA Station Hospital.

Barely a month later, on April 7, Cadet 4th Class Monico de Guzman died while being treated at the Baguio General Hospital for injuries he sustained from severe beatings he received in the academy.

In 2002, two cadets were convicted of homicide in Domingo’s death, and were sentenced to 12 years in prison.

2019: Darwin Dormitorio

In the last month of his life, Cadet 4th Class Darwin Dormitorio lived according to the whims of some upperclassmen in his squad. They humiliated and tortured him over petty things such as a missing pair of combat boots and for screaming “like a faggot” when they electrocuted his genitals.

The 20-year-old plebe soldiered on until his body gave way to the countless kicks and punches inflicted on him by his fellow cadets.

After he died of cardiac arrest as a result of internal bleeding on September 18, the police investigating his case said Dormitorio's time at the academy had been a “living hell.”

The case rocked the PMA. Its superintendent and commandant of cadets both resigned. So did the commanding officer and attending physician of the PMA Station Hospital, under whose watch Dormitorio had gone in and out for treatment of injuries that could only have been from hazing.

The cadets directly responsible for his death have been dismissed and are expected to face criminal charges.

What's the remedy?

Even so, Lacson feels sorry for Dormitorio’s tormentors – and killers.

“While we sympathize with the family of the late Dormitorio, we can’t help but also pity those who are now facing murder charges, violation of the anti-hazing law. Because they will be – There’s really that big possibility that they’ll be spending the rest of their lives in jail,” the senator said during the DND budget hearing.

“But how do we remedy this?” he then asked his fellow PMA alumni. How do they fix something they couldn’t fully bring themselves to admit is broken?

They all went through it. It made them who they are, as some of them proudly say. Could they then condemn a practice that, although never sanctioned by the academy itself, was a definitive part of their experience as cadets?

“But times have changed,” the former police chief added. He, after all, authored the amended anti-hazing law that finally defined hazing as inherently a crime, regardless of whether it results in someone’s injury or death.

The academy’s leadership has included hazing in the cadets’ “honor system,” that is, their tactical officers are now encouraged to routinely ask them if they have been victims or perpetrators of hazing, and they are honor-bound to answer honestly. The honor system dictates that cadets never lie, cheat, or steal.

Ultimately, the change must begin from the upperclassmen – all the academy’s alumni – according to the new PMA superintendent, Rear Admiral Allan Cusi.

All PMA graduates must stop “glamorizing maltreatment,” Cusi said, as though one’s capacity to endure pain and suffering were the measure of a soldier’s worth.

Cadets must have “heart and soul” as “warriors of the motherland,” Cusi said as he took over the leadership of the academy earlier this week. Because that loyalty in their motto is not so much to one another or the academy or the uniformed service as it ought to be to the motherland. – Rappler.com

FALSE: ‘New evidence of widespread cheating’ by Robredo in 2016 VP election protest

$
0
0

Screenshot of website article saying there is 'new evidence' vs Robredo in the ongoing election protest concerning the 2016 vice presidential polls

Claim: New evidence of "widespread cheating" has been reported against Vice President Leni Robredo in the ongoing electoral protest questioning the results of the 2016 vice presidential elections.

The website pinastrends.xyz on September 28 published a post with the headline, "Breaking! Panibagong Ebidensya ng Malawakang Dayaan ng Kampo ni Leni" (Breaking! New Evidence of Widespread Cheating of Camp of Leni).

The article featured a post from Facebook user Anthony Sumagui to support its claim. Sumagui cited a supposed resolution from the Presidential Electoral Tribunal (PET) ordering municipal treasurers and election officers in some towns in Camarines Sur – Robredo's home province – to explain issues or irregularities found in election paraphernalia.

According to online tool Crowdtangle, the article has been shared at least 1,652 times after being posted by Facebook pages supportive of Ferdinand Marcos Jr – who filed the election protest against Robredo – and presidential daughter Sara Duterte, like Sara Duterte for President 2022 Elections, Marcos Loyalist, and Duterte Marcos Supporters.

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The said evidence is not new. It has been reported over a year ago, in mid-2018.

The PET resolution indeed made the resolution, as reported by ABS-CBN News on July 6, 2018. The PET resolution was dated June 19, 2018, and concerned municipal treasurers and chairmen of the board of election inspectors (BEI) from Iriga City, Tinambac, and Tigaon.

A separate resolution on April 24, 2018, ordered municipal treasurers in 4 other Camarines Sur towns to explain the issue of "wet ballots." This was also reported in Manila Bulletin in May 2018.

Since then, however, there has been no ruling yet on whether these issues or irregularities constitute cheating, because PET proceedings are confidential in nature.

The PET has also not issued a decision, as of writing, on the first stage of the 2016 vice presidential vote recount, which is part of Marcos' election protest against Robredo. The Supreme Court, sitting as the PET, scheduled for October 8 a new round of deliberations. (READ: Justice Caguioa finished with report on pilot recount in Marcos poll protest)

In addition, below the full text of Sumagui's featured Facebook post in the article was only a screenshot of his July 31, 2018, post, not an embed, which would have reflected the timestamp of his post.

Similar claims on the 2016 VP election protest have popped up in recent months, like a false, rehashed claim on the "final, official" vote count, and a false claim on a PET ad hoc committee "confirming" cheating allegations in the provinces covered by the initial recount. – Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.


FALSE: Video of 'young people died after drinking fake beer in China'

$
0
0

Claim: A group of young people in China supposedly died because of drinking fake beer, a viral video on Facebook claimed

The page Taxiuncle Group posted the video with the caption, “Fake beer in China killed a group of young drinkers who unknowingly had too many of it.”

The people in the video were unconscious and lying on chairs on a street. 

The 14-second video was shared more than 22,000 times and has garnered more than 8,000 reactions and 1,100 comments on Facebook. The claim was spotted through Facebook's fact check tool Claim Check. 

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The people in the video were intoxicated, not dead, according to a Taiwan-based news channel that refuted the claim that the people consumed fake alcohol. 

Using Amnesty International’s YouTube DataViewer, a video verification tool, Rappler found online content that matches the video thumbnail. 

Screenshot of Youtube DataViewer reverse image search

A reverse image search showed two different false claims that were attributed to the video. One said people supposedly died because of drinking fake wine in Dongguan, China. Another said they were poisoned after eating crayfish. 

Two official news reports from China debunked these rumors which initially circulated within Chinese social networking site Weibo. 

A news report by Shanghai-based daily newspaper Liberation Daily, translated to English through Google Translate, said 5 people were in a small lobster shop in Guangzhou past midnight on September 14. Three of them became unconscious because of drinking excessive liquor and beer.

All 5 were admitted to the Baiyun District Chinese Medicine Hospital and were found to be intoxicated. Only those unconscious were treated. Blood test results showed there were no abnormalities among those who were treated.

A separate report on SETN Sanli News Network, a Taiwan-based online news channel, said that the video was not taken in Dongguan and the people in the video were not drinking fake wine. They dismissed the claim as a “rumor.” 

According to the SETN Sanli News Network report, the video was originally circulated on the messaging app Line before it went viral on Weibo.

Facebook page Taxiuncle Group, which shared the claim, has around 12,000 followers. According to its "About" section, the page is a “community network for sharing info.” While it is not specifically described as a Filipino community, a number of comments on the alleged fake beer story were in Filipino. – Glenda Marie Castro/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.

‘Taking selfies part of public service’ – Isko Moreno

$
0
0

 SELFIE TIME. Manila Mayor Isko Moreno takes selfies with eager Manileños. Photo from Manila PIO

To know that Manila Mayor Isko Moreno has arrived at a scene, one must only look for a swarm of people with their phones held out. They want to take a selfie with Moreno.

This is true from flag ceremonies up to late-night dinners with foundations. The constant stream of people pulling Moreno aside has in fact been a cause of delay for many of his events, with requests  from guests and bystanders stretching what should be a one-minute stroll from the Bonifacio Monument to 10 minutes of photo opportunities. Entering venues take long too as people approach him.

Is there a point where the mayor thinks it has become too much?

According to Moreno, he does not mind at all, because it comes with the job.

“I look at it (taking selfies) as a public service also. If I can make you smile, [give a] certain level of happiness, why not? Because, you know, governance is about making your people happy, superficially and economically,” Moreno said in a Rappler Talk interview on Wednesday, October 3.

He added: “Hanggat kaya, hanggat walang maaapektuhang oras, I try to accommodate as many as possible (As long as we can, and that the schedule will not be disrupted, I try to accommodate as many as possible).”

Moreno the mobile mayor

The remark stresses how Moreno values the power of mobile phones and the internet in his administration.

Within his first 100 days in office, he has reached out to Manileños primarily through his high-powered Facebook page, where his public information team of millennials always makes sure he is live, and where all photographs of his events are posted.

There are commenters on social media who have flagged the overzealous posting as a sign of Moreno being an “epal” (attention-seeker), but Moreno and his public information team believe it is only part of his “engagement” as the mayor.

In an earlier interview with Rappler, public relations expert and former Ateneo de Manila University Communication Department chair Severino Sarmenta said the Facebook strategy works especially when reporters have other issues to cover aside from Moreno. Through his Facebook, he can directly speak to his followers.

At the end of the interview with Rappler, Moreno said one of the things he has learned since assuming office is the importance of “changing the public’s mindset” with his communication team.  And this includes pausing for hundreds of people a day to show that their mayor can smile with them even for a few seconds. – Rappler.com

IN NUMBERS: QC Mayor Joy Belmonte's first 100 days

$
0
0

100 DAYS. Quezon City Mayor Joy Belmonte delivers her first State of the City Address on October 7, 2019. Photo by Darren Langit/Rappler

MANILA, Philippines – First-term Quezon City Mayor Joy Belmonte on Monday, October 7, cited unfinished business she inherited, challenges she faced, and and plans for more services during her  first 100 days as mayor. 

In her State of the City Address, she said the city government had dealt so far with road clearing operations, African swine fever, and the pressure to uphold the promises she made when she was sworn in on June 30.

She let the numbers speak for themselves.

Road clearing

20-30new QC Bayanihan sa Lansangan roads (alternative roads)
2,250new registered vendors

Belmonte said the city government went "above and beyond" the mandate of the Department of the Interior and Local Government to clear national, primary, and secondary roads, and Mabuhay lanes. To further decongest traffic, the Quezon City government added 20 to 30 alternative roads – dubbed QC Bayanihan sa Lansangan Road Networks after Task Force Bayanihan sa Lansangan.

The task force coordinated multiple departments of the city government as well as the city's 142 barangays.

She added that vendors displaced by the clearing operations were encouraged to continue their vending inside public markets or in alternative vending sites that do not obstruct roads. The relocation of displaced vendors included their profiling, registration, and handing out of official IDs.

Belmonte said the number of registered vendors rose from 950 when they took over to 3,200 at present. 

"Sa pamamagitan nito, hindi na sila muling mapgsasamantalahan at pagkakakitaan ng mga sindikato o protektor, at magiging legal na silang mga manininda sa mga government-identified vending sites," she said.

(This way, they will no longer be taken advantage of by syndicates, and they will be legal vendors in government-identified vending sites.)

African swine fever

4,466culled pigs
P13,398,000financial assistance given to hog raisers

Following the outbreak of African swine fever (ASF) in 3 Quezon City barangays, Belmonte urged illegal hog raisers to surrender their pigs for culling and receive P3,000 per head. 

So far, 4,466 pigs from ASF-infected areas have been culled, and more than P13 million in financial assistance has been provided to affected hog raisers. 

While Belmonte earlier announced an allocation of P10 million for financial assistance to be provided to backyard hog raisers, she said the city administrator found a way to raise the budget to P15 million.

Social services

As mayor, it was clear where Belmonte's priorities lie: better and quicker facilitation of social services.

Financial assistance for fire victims

4,600families
44fire incidents
P6.5 millionfinancial assistance extended
P8,000increase in financial assistance

Belmonte said 4,600 families from 44 fire incidents have been given financial aid amounting to around P6.5 million, clearing the backlog incurred from November 2018.

Apart from this, an ordinance has been filed that will raise financial assistance for fire victims to to P10,000, from P2,000, which Belmonte said had not been changed for 20 years.

Burial assistance

P15,000increase in financial assistance

Belmonte said burial assistance provided to citizens will be raised from the original amount of P10,000 to a full package of P25,000. 

She added that the death benefit assistance worth P5,000 extended to family members of deceased senior citizens would be distributed within the month, clearing the backlog originating from 2017.

Senior citizen assistance

6,500indigent social pension applications expedited

Aside from being expedited, the processing of over 6,500 indigent social pension applications to receive aid from the Department of Social Welfare and Development will soon be made available at barangays. This will allow applicants to avoid the inconvenience of going to and lining up at City Hall.

Informal settler families

429beneficiaries who were awarded land titles
4,000beneficiaries to be accommodated in two properties

Some 215,000 informal settler families reside in Quezon City, and Belmonte aims to address this by implementing a new shelter plan. The city government will purchase land where a new township will be built.

This initiative, modeled after Singapore, will include the construction of mid- to high-rise buildings with various payment options for the units.

Belmonte said 429 beneficiaries had been awarded titles under the local government's direct sale program and community mortgage program, with more to be awarded in the following months.

"Marami sa kanila ang mga tumanda na kahihintay sa titulo ng kanilang mga bahay, kaya naman atin po itong ginawan ng agarang aksiyon," Belmonte said. (A lot of them have grown old waiting for the titles to their land, so we prioritized this.)

Healthcare

P1.9 billionproposed budget increase for medicines
32new permanent positions for doctors
P2,000proposed budget increase for medical assistance

From P550,000, Belmonte proposed to increase the budget for medicines to P2 billion in 2020. 

"We pray that the city council supports this increase when they review our proposed health budget," she said.

Thirty-two permanent positions will also be opened for doctors in local government health facilities.

Medical assistance will be raised from P3,000 to P5,000.

Peace and order

17%drop in index crimes compared to last year
745%decrease in the congestion rate of Camp Karingal's female dormitory
96CCTV cameras restored along key junctions and thoroughfares
148CCTV cameras to be restored by the end of October

Belmonte said there had been a drop of 17% in index crimes compared to this time in 2018, based on data from the Philippine National Police. 

She stated that the congestion rate of the female dormitory at Camp Karingal had been brought down from 1,243% to 498%. There are now beds and showers in each cell, and more space to exercise.

Over 96 CCTV cameras have been restored to monitor key junctions and thoroughfares in the city. The remaining 148 city-owned CCTV cameras will be restored by the end of October.

Ease of doing business

15,000environmental clearances issued in 3 months
328.6%increase in approved clearances per day
3 minutestime needed to release occupational permits

Belmonte cited that while only 11,000 environmental clearances were handed out from January to June 2019, 15,000 were issued in the 3-month period of July to September 2019.

She added that in 2018, 30% of all business permits issued were not in allowable zones and did not have locational clearances.

The number of approved clearances per day rose from 35 in January to June to 150 since July.

"Occupational permits can now be released as quickly as 3 minutes and, in keeping with our mandate of speedy services, occupational permits can be processed onsite starting January of next year for businesses with 300 employees or more," Belmonte added.

Environment

320cubic meters of trash and dirt removed from rivers

Belmonte acknowledged the continuous decloggin of the city's sewerage systems and the dredging of waterways conducted by the Engineering Department.

Within 100 days, Belmonte said, 320 cubic meteres of trash and dirt were removed from the city's rivers. 

"We are happy to report that, since our efforts started, the reports of flooding have dramatically gone down," she said.

Infrastructure

7priority infrastructure projects

Belmonte cited 7 priority infrastructure projects: a multi-purpose hall in Barangay Sto Domingo, the Damayang Lagi barangay hall, and the redevelopment of 4 public markets.

The Damayang Lagi barangay hall was earlier demolished as part of the mandated road clearing operations.

The retrofitting and renovation of the Quezon City General Hospital will also be conducted, along with the inclusion of a new and improved dialysis center.

Representation

1,600civil society organizations accredited

Belmonte stressed the importance of increased representation in order to achieve improved services through good governance. She said people's participation will be made more vibrant by the increased number of civil society organizations (CSOs).

"From just over 381 accredited CSOs in 2001, when my father began his first term, we now have more than 1,600 civil society organizations representing many more sectors, including solo parents and [LGBTQIA+]. Tunay na isinasakatuparan natin ang ating adhikain na kasama ang lahat sa pag-unlad," she said. (We working towards realizing our goal of including everyone towards progress.)

Quezon City will be celebrating its 80th year in October. – Rappler.com

 

China at 70: 'Fantasy of cordial relations' with the Philippines

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines – On a podium at the center of the Gate of Heavenly Peace, Chinese President Xi Jingping stood tall above a portrait of Mao Zedong as he watched a parade of military might cross the length of Beijing’s Avenue of Eternal Peace.

The image of the two powerful Chinese leaders – one who was the country’s founding father and another who was born after the revolution that birthed it – looked on as the staccato of 15,000 soldiers marching in unison filled the space below them.

A showcase of advanced intercontinental ballistic missiles, hypersonic drones, and fighter jets were put on display as a cultural showcase of China’s leaders completed the anniversary parade.

China had much to celebrate. On October 1, 2019, all eyes were on the Asian giant as it marked 7 decades since the founding of the People’s Republic of China in 1949. The occasion was historic, with China now the longest surviving communist regime in the world – outlasting the former Soviet Union by one year and counting.

SHOW OF FORCE. Chinese President Xi Jinping (7th L) attends a military parade with former presidents Hu Jintao (6th L) and Jiang Zemin (8th L) in Tiananmen Square in Beijing on October 1, 2019, to mark the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People'•s Republic of China. Photo by Greg Baker/AFP

The vast parade was unimaginable 70 years ago but in the decades that separated Xi and Mao, China had grown from poverty to prosperity – becoming one of the most powerful states not only in the region, but the world.

No force can stop us

Years of playing catch up were over. China’s development boosted it to the spot of the world’s second largest economy, growing to 90 trillion RMB ($13.6 trillion) as of 2018. An economic powerhouse, China’s celebration showed the world it was no longer the same nation that once struggled to compete.

By Xi’s own words, the founding of the PRC 70 years ago, marked “the end of more than 100 years of humiliation and misery the country suffered since modern times.” China, in fact, is now a dominant player rivalling a superpower in the United States and shaping the world today.

To mark the historic moment, Xi dressed in a crisp grey Mao suit as he stood on the same spot Mao had 70 years ago. And in a speech that called for unity and peace, hard work, and a commitment to the Communist Party of China, Xi declared: “Today a socialist China is standing in the East of the world and there is no force that can shake the status of this great nation.”

“No force,” he said, “can stop the Chinese people and the Chinese nation forging ahead” as he vowed China would pursue a path of “peaceful development.”

MILITARY MIGHT. Chinese troops march during a military parade in Tiananmen Square in Beijing on October 1, 2019. Photo by Greg Baker/AFP

But forging ahead has its costs, now unravelling among China's citizens and neighbors.

Dissenting voices

About 1,965 kilometers from the capital of Beijing, nearly 4 months of unrest over China’s tightening grip on Hong Kong crippled the city as protestors took to the streets on China’s 70th founding anniversary.

“No celebration. Only demonstration,” leading Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong tweeted.

There would be none of the usual festivities like a flag raising ceremony and fireworks to commemorate the occasion in the harbour city. Instead, those activities were called off and China’s 70th anniversary in Hong Kong ended with aggressive police tactics resulting in one protester shot with a live round and one journalist permanently blinded in one eye.

“Hong Kong’s Today; The World’s Tomorrow? The Chinese Communist Party is tearing Hong Kong apart,” Wong decried. “If we fall, who will be the next?"

CLASH. Hong Kong police detain a protester (C) during demonstrations in the Wanchai district in Hong Kong on October 1 as the city observes the National Day holiday to mark the 70th anniversary of communist China's founding. Photo by Nicolas Asfouri/AFP

This seeming split in messaging is not confined to China’s borders. Outside it, one need not look further than the Philippines to see this.

In a ballroom of the Shangri-La Hotel in Makati City, China Ambassador to the Philippines Zhao Jianhua told a room filled with Philippine officials, foreign dignitaries, and journalists that 70 years of communist rule in China “achieved a miracle of development unprecedented in human history.”

“In just a few decades, China has completed a course that took developed countries several hundred years…. Today China is marching forward along the peaceful path of rejuvenation,” he said in a speech on September 26.

Like other countries it boasted having diplomatic relations with (from 18 in 1949 to 179 in 2019), the Philippines, Zhao said, shared in China’s successes.

Warming ties between Manila and Beijing under the Duterte administration have seen China become the Philippines top trading partner, its largest source of both imports and exports, and its second largest source of tourists.

China has also become one of the country’s largest sources of foreign investments and aid, with as much as $398 million in grants and $273 million in soft loans given as of 2018, Zhao said.

The Philippines, he added, can also expect some $421 million more in grants to be provided from 2019 to 2022 and “more than a dozen” flagship infrastructure projects to be completed in the “next few years.”

'DESPITE CHALLENGES.' President Rodrigo Duterte and Chinese President Xi Jinping before the start of the bilateral meeting at the Diaoyutai State Guesthouse in Beijing on August 29, 2019. Malacañang photo

“China is committed to being a good neighbor, a good partner and a good friend of the Philippines,” Zhao said.

But according to University of the Philippines political scientist Herman Kraft, cordial ties between Beijing and Manila are only evident at the official level. On the ground, Filipinos’ attitude towards China has repeatedly shown a lack of trust.

A recent survey by the Social Weather Stations (SWS) showed this, with only two in 10 Filipinos believing China has good intentions for the Philippines as of April 2019.

“China has consistently emerged as a country viewed with suspicion by Filipinos especially when compared with how the US measures up among Filipinos. The cordial relations nurtured by President Duterte has not led to Filipinos welcoming the Chinese with open arms,” Kraft told Rappler.

Chinese nationals working in the Philippines can be caught in the crosshairs of Filipino's suspicions over China. In Philippine offshore gaming operations, for instance, many Chinese workers coming to the Philippines were poor and often exploited by their employers. They are also exposed to racism amid tensions between the two countries. 

According to a report from risk-analysis company PSA Philippines Consultancy, there were also at least 21 incidents of Chinese nationals being kidnapped in 2019 in relation to gambling debts. This was over 5 times the number of kidnappings related to gambling debts in 2017 (4) and 2018 (4) and over 20 times more than the number in 2016 (0) and 2015 (0).

Yet while both Manila and Beijing boast of friendlier ties, Chinese investments in the Philippines have also yet to deliver more than halfway into the Duterte administration.

Foreign Secretary Teodoro “Teddyboy” Locsin Jr admitted this much during an interview with Asia Society Policy Institute president Kevin Rudd where the top diplomat said Chinese investments in the Philippines have “hardly materialized.”

“Yes, we sign up to this and that agreement but they hardly materialize. They hardly materialize and if you would compare to Japanese investments and official assistance – nothing,” Locsin said.

FRIENDLY TIES. The Philippine government is cozying up to China for infrastructure deals. File photo by Ted Aljibe/AFP

For Greg Poling of the Washington-based Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative (AMTI) of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), problems on the economic may mean that “sooner or later Manila will have to admit that Chinese economic largesse is not what it was supposed to be.”

Trouble in high waters

It's in the maritime area that a gap between what Chinese officials say and what happens in reality is most apparent. 

“China is committed to maintaining peace and stability with the Philippines,” Zhao claimed as he added China had the “greatest stake” in safeguarding peace in the maritime area since more than 60% of its trade and energy involved the South China Sea.

“It is our belief that the South China Sea Issue is not the sum-total of China-Philippines relations, nor disputes the sum total of the South China Sea issue,” he added. It's a line often said by both Philippine and Chinese officials. 

RIPPED APART. In this photo, damage to Gem-Ver is seen after a Chinese ship hit and tore away its stern. File photo by LeAnne Jazul/Rappler

But China has bullied the Philippines and other Southeast Asian countries with claims in the South China Sea. 

Just a few months before PRC’s 70th founding anniversary, the sinking and abandonment of Philippine fishing boat Gem-Ver by a Chinese vessel put the spotlight on the Duterte administration’s policy towards West Philippine Sea and China’s aggressive tactics in the maritime area, and tested Duterte's warm ties with Beijing.

Months after this incident, reports from the Philippines defense departments also indicated Chinese fishing vessels do more than just fish in the West Philippine Sea, but are part of China’s strategy to control the resource-rich waters and deny Filipinos access to their exclusive economic zone.

A recent report from the Asia Maritime Transparency initiative said data from Chinese ships’ automatic identification system (AIS) showed Chinese coast guard vessels (CCG) were patrolling Luconia Shoals, Ayungin Shoal (Second Thomas Shoal), and Panatag Shoal (Scarborough Shoal) more frequently as part of its efforts to project power in the maritime area.

Photo from Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative of the Center for Strategic and International Studies

Data showed there was at least one ship broadcasting from Luconia on 258 of the last 365 days, at least one ship was broadcasting at Second Thomas on 215 days, and from Scarborough for 162 days. While other CCG vessels in the South China Sea don’t broadcast AIS, AMTI said CCG vessels in these areas “want to be seen.”

Why? The patrol pattern of CCG vessels in these areas signalled Beijing’s objective to create a “routine, highly visible Chinese presence at key sites” over which it claims sovereignty but does not have any permanent facilities, AMTI said.

China’s attempt to maintain a semi-permanent presence in these areas long enough, the think-tank warned, may become a “compelling blueprint for extending Chinese administration across other reefs and shoals.”

'Fantasy of cordial relations'

This is largely why Filipinos have little trust in China.

Most Filipinos agree that the Philippine government "should assert its right to the islands in the West Philippine Sea,” according to a recent survey by SWS

WEST PHILIPPINE SEA. Protesters march near Malacanang ahead of the anniversary of the Hague ruling on the South China Sea on July 9, 2019. Photo by Lito Borras/Rappler

That polls have shown how much Filipinos withhold their trust from China indicated that Filipinos filter their view and attitudes towards China through the West Philippine Sea issue, according to Kraft.

“Objectively, the bilateral relationship is more than just the West Philippine Sea/South China Sea, but the latter is the precondition that shapes attitudes and perspectives towards China,” he said.

For Poling, Philippine and Chinese government efforts to promote an “image of cordiality and paper over differences," especially on the South China Sea, is not sustainable. (READ: Philippines loses to China 3 years fter Hague ruling)

“Chinese harassment of Filipinos in the South China Sea hasn’t decreased under Duterte; it has increased (the difference is just that Manila tries not to publicize it),” he said.

“Sooner or later we’ll see a repeat of the Gem-Ver sinking, and next time it might well end with dead mariners. China is not prepared to compromise its claims, and is committed to use paramilitary force to assert them, so sooner or later that will lead to another incident that undermines the fantasy of cordial relations,” Poling added.

This matters not just for the Philippines, but other countries in Southeast Asia and countries like the US who are players in the South China Sea dispute.

After all, as Former Akbayan representative and State University of New York adjunct professor of sociology Walden Bello said, it is in the South China Sea where Beijing is most acutely confronted with the choice to continue its aggressive tactics or “take these criticism seriously and work with other governments… to strike out on a different and more benign path.”

“How it resolves its differences with its smaller neighbors there can provide a template for the way it meets the criticisms that have been levelled at it elsewhere,” Bello said in a Focus on the Global South publication released October 2.

As for the Philippines, Poling said: "Sooner or later, Manila will need to make a choice to stand up or accede to Chinese control of the West Philippine Sea. And every day it ignores that reality, China’s position gets stronger and the Philippines’ gets weaker."

ASSERT RIGHTS. Protesters condemn on July 12, 2019 China's harassment of Filipinos in the West Philippine Sea. Photo by Maria Tan/Rappler   

Policy challenge for Philippines

As China enters its 70th year under communist rule, where might its relationship with the Philippines be headed?

According to Kraft, official ties will remain cordial at least until the end of the Duterte administration.

“Over the short term, that is until the end of the Duterte Administration, the relationship will remain as it is…. Beyond that, however, it will depend on who will take over as President of the Philippines,” he said.

Unlike China, Kraft said the “proverbial short attention span of Philippine policy-making,” may also put Filipinos at a disadvantage as Beijing’s foreign policy “plays a long-term positional game in the region.”

Chinese President Xi Jinping (C) attends a military parade with former presidents Hu Jintao (L) and Jiang Zemin in Tiananmen Square in Beijing on October 1, 2019, to mark the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People's Republic of China. Photo by Greg Baker/AFP

This comes in stark contrast to Xi’s leadership where his recent moves to abolish term limits can be seen as the concentration of power and authority in his hands.

Calling for unity as “iron and steel” and a “source of strength,” the Chinese president asserted following the the communist party “enabled the Chinese people and the Chinese nation to move forward against all risks and challenges, from one victory to another."

With such thinking and a long-term vision from Beijing, Kraft said it would do well for Philippine officials to work with the Chinese foreign ministry to ensure working relationships were “not dependent on the political exigencies of the next administration, and certainly not based on how badly the situation in the West Philippine Sea is going.”

“Otherwise, the relationship will swing according to the politics of the day.” – Rappler.com

TOP PHOTO: 'NEW AT 70'. Chinese participants take part in a gala in Tiananmen Square in Beijing on October 1, 2019, to mark the 70th anniversary of the founding of the People'sRepublic of China. Photo by Noel Celis/AFP

Vico Sotto, the Prince of Pasig, must prepare for war

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines – Pasig’s young new mayor, Vico Sotto, posts about some achievement on his official Facebook page – for instance, a thousand-plus scholars added to the roster – and easily 10,000 people hit the Like” button. Meanwhile, in some corner of the city, the previous mayor he had supplanted, Bobby Eusebio, attends a fiesta or a funeral, shaking hands with people and giving away knick-knacks as though he didn’t lose the last election.

Everywhere around the city, the letter E – for “Eusebio” – remains emblazoned on curbside railings, schoolhouses, public halls, and almost every government service vehicle: vestiges of the family’s 27-year reign in Pasig.

Sotto, after just a single term of 3 years as city councilor, thwarted Eusebio’s bid to take that number to 30. If there was anyone who could beat a Eusebio in an election, it was Sotto, and a group of influential old-timers, who call themselves Tambuli ng Pasig (Clarion of Pasig), had recognized that and honed in on him as a potential liberator from the tired, old regime.

“Heto, may karisma, guwapo, matangkad, maputi, artistahin,” said Eli Salonga, a member of Tambuli. (This one has charisma, is handsome, tall, fair-skinned, star material.)

But, more importantly, “isang mabait na tao, mabuting tao,” added Noel Medina, the civic group’s president. (A kind person, a good person.)

The son of two big movie stars, Coney Reyes and Vic Sotto, Vico Sotto was somebody without even trying. And although he is a new, squeaky-clean personality in politics, his surname links him to two senators: one, from the distant past, his great grandfather Vicente Sotto; and the other, his uncle, current Senate President Vicente Sotto III.

The neophyte councilor was a rare confluence of two essential requirements for political success: leadership potential and marketability. But his good moral character sealed the deal: Vico Sotto could make a good mayor.

And so Tambuli, among whose founders are relatives of the late Senate President Jovito Salonga, got behind Sotto for the May 2019 elections and campaigned for him.

“Alam mo ba kung ano’ng ginawa mo? Inagaw mo ang 27-year-old multi-billion kingdom kina Eusebio,” Medina told Sotto after he won the mayoralty. (You know what you just did? You grabbed a 27-year-old multi-billion kingdom from the Eusebios.)

It was congratulatory, but Medina also meant it as a warning.

Ang tingin namin sa laban na to, giyera (We see this fight as a war). This is a political war,” he went on. “At yung kalaban natin, buhay pa at kumpleto ang armas para durugin ka (and our enemy is still alive and fully armed to crush you).”

Marching orders: end corruption

One morning in October, a middle-aged woman threw a fit at city hall’s service floor, where people queue up at different counters for every mundane errand involving the city government.

The woman was trying to pay her overdue taxes under a compromise agreement and, perhaps feeling a little humiliated by her situation, she flared up when she saw the clerk call for the documents of a caucasian man who was standing behind her. Incensed at being overlooked, she flew into a rage so big that Winnie Rayos Dimanlig, head of the city’s complaints desk, came running to her from her office on the far end of the hall.

Dimanlig found the woman berating the clerk, who was trying to explain that the foreigner had actually arrived earlier than her and was on his way back from the cashier to submit his receipt.

The clerk’s patience was running out. Dimanlig tried to calm the situation.

Yung pagsasalita nung nanay, mataas din ang ere. Ang kausap niya dun ay yung isang tao na may pinagdaraanan na mabigat na problema at the moment,” Dimanlig recalled, chuckling a bit at the meltdown she tried to sort out. (The woman’s tone was condescending. The clerk she was dealing with happened to be going through some big problem at the moment.)

Just then, the woman started to faint. Dimanlig called for an ambulance, and the woman was brought to a nearby hospital.

It was one of the more extreme cases Dimanlig and her team of 10 personnel have had to handle at the Ugnayan sa Pasig (Touchpoint at Pasig), the complaints desk and hotline Sotto set up on his 3rd week as mayor.

The Ugnayan is the embodiment of Sotto’s marching orders to the city’s bureaucracy to shape up, not just in giving courteous, professional frontline service to citizens but, more importantly, to end corruption.

“The employees are still from the previous ano, ’di ba?” Dimanlig said, avoiding mention of Eusebio’s administration. She is one of Sotto’s few fresh hires, her position justified by the new office she leads.

“So the reality is that some of them would still do what they would,” she trails off, implying old habits and indiscretions.

“At saka yung mga nanghihingi ng, you know, nagse-send ng feelers na, aasikasuhin ko to pero – May ganun pa rin,” Dimanlig went on. (And there are still those who ask for, you know, who send feelers that they would fix this but–.)

Bribes, she couldn’t bring herself to say, because she shares an entire floor with bureaucrats among whom are a few who have been reported to her office, and are now being investigated for alleged corruption.

In fact, ugnayan” has become a verb among city hall employees. “Uy, na-ugnayan ka raw (Hey, I heard you were ugnayan-ed),” they would tease a colleague who’d been reported to the desk or hotline, Dimanlig said. She takes it as a good sign.

“We have a pretty good batting average,” Dimanlig was proud to say, adding that reports of officers trying to fleece citizens have declined in the past couple of months.

“Just one or two [are reported now],” she said.

TRANSITION. Pasig City Mayor Vico Sotto says managing the first ever transition in administration since Pasig became a city in 1995 is challenging. Photo from Vico Sotto's official Facebook page

‘Like their private property’

The villagers were ready with an armada of questions and reasons to convince Mayor Sotto not to widen the canal between their informal settlement and a flood control dike beyond two meters. Any more and it might mean their eviction. So they steeled themselves. They were resolute. They won’t take no for an answer.

But the moment Sotto alighted from his van in the riverside community in Barangay Santolan one Friday morning in August, the small crowd of villagers were starstruck. The women sighed and giggled, “Ang guwapo! (How handsome!)” Even the men couldn’t help craning their necks to get a better view, a broad grin on their faces.

Although he could not completely grant the villagers’ request, he did assure them that anyone who would be evicted to make way for the wider canal would be relocated within Pasig, and he promised that he wouldn’t leave them homeless.

Sotto’s charisma and earnest manner come handy when he needs to be stern. He has something of his comedian father in his ability to douse tense moments with jokes or self-deprecating quips.

He needs it because, to an undetermined number of people in his bureaucracy, he is bad news. To demand professionalism from people who think they are shortchanged, or integrity from those who have been benefitting from the corrupt system, is political suicide.

He needs these people to like him, or at least get as many other people as possible to like him in order to drown out the haters.

And so he must win them over even as he tries to discipline them.

When Sotto won the election and promised reforms, a shockwave went through city hall among employees who feared for their jobs.

But Sotto, the mabait (kind), promised to keep them – even the rotten, if they would shape up.

Although he slammed the city’s “notorious” traffic enforcers for fleecing motorists, he offered them an opportunity to secure their tenure by reforming themselves. Those caught still exacting bribes despite the mayor’s warning were fired and investigated.

In August, Sotto posted a photo of an empty office at city hall. The occupant had been fired for “questionable practices and abusive behavior,” and he took everything with him on his way out.

For Sotto, it was a glaring example of what he was up against: “people who treat the government like their private property.”

‘Two governments’ in Pasig

Kay Enteng kami (We’re for Enteng),” the words were printed across the chest on a shirt a man was wearing during that public consultation meeting about the canal in Barangay Santolan.

Vicente “Enteng” Eusebio became mayor of Pasig in 1992 and remained in power until he used up the 3 consecutive terms allowed by the law. His wife Soledad took over for one term until 2004, when Enteng ran again and won.

In 2007, Enteng’s son Bobby won as mayor for two successive terms, after which Bobby’s wife Maribel went for a single term. Bobby was back in 2016, and then tried for re-election last May, when he lost to Sotto.

The Eusebios knew how to push Pasigueños’ buttons, Tambuli’s Salonga said. They should know; they helped Enteng win his first term in 1992. Back then, he was the Bulakeño migrant who offered something new, before he got too comfortable in city hall.

The Eusebios strived to be seen at as many “kasal, binyag, libing (wedding, christening, funeral)" as they could, said Tambuli’s Medina, also the president of the the Institute for Political and Electoral Reform.

It’s a basic trapo– traditional politician – tactic they wish Sotto would use for his own good, if the goal is to earn the people’s loyalty.

But Sotto has his way of doing things. During the campaign, Bobby Eusebio put on full variety shows “complete with macho dancers” during his sorties, Medina said. Sotto, meanwhile, wanted to stand at street corners and atop trucks like a preacher, and there propagate his gospel of reform and good governance.

The Tambuli guys said they insisted on at least a bare stage with a decent sound system, but Sotto wouldnt hear any of that.

Watching Sotto do his thing, his veteran campaigners learned what it means to be unconventional.

Aba, parang tama ito eh (Well, this seems right),” Medina recalled exclaiming.

Now that he is mayor, Sotto still does things as he sees fit, especially when it comes to his public relations: no media scrum. Hardly any TV interviews. No song and dance crew. No banners or fliers. No glitz and glamor, although he could definitely bring that on with his showbusiness connections.

Instead, he goes down to tricycle stations and clogged streets to see the problems for himself, holds townhall meetings, command conferences, and graces the occasional street party unannounced, and then everything ends up as photos or videos on his official Facebook and Twitter profiles, where he has several hundred thousand followers.

Because he wants to focus on the work, Sotto would say when turning down a request for a media interview. He wants to work silently, and the work will speak for itself.

Why bother with the conventional fanfare? Didn’t he win by being unconventional?

So far, Sotto has reinvigorated the city’s public health care system, beefed up its scholarship program, sorted out tussles involving tricycle unions, cleared many roads and sidewalks of obstructions, set up freedom of information kiosks at libraries, and perhaps, most importantly, motivated young people to get involved in how the city government is run.

Sotto is doing well and covering his campaign promises, Salonga and Medina said, but he is not doing enough.

“Ang problema namin is, Eusebio is breathing down our necks. Andiyan lang eh. Nasa likod mo lang eh. Kadikit mo na,” Salonga said. (Our problem is, Eusebio is breathing down our necks. He’s just there, right behind you, almost at you.)

A quick look at Bobby Eusebio’s official Facebook page shows the former mayor still going about his usual business attending every kasal, binyag, libing, and more, sponsoring events and even reposting photos of old projects, creating the impression that he is still in charge, still on top.

Salonga said he even saw the Eusebio couple lead a recent town fiesta parade aboard government vehicles still bearing their names and taglines.

“Ironically, dalawa ang gobyerno sa Pasig: ang gobyerno ni Mayor Vico at yung gobyernong nakaraan,” Salonga lamented. (Ironically, there are two governments in Pasig: that of Mayor Vico and the past government.)

“Habang itong mayor natin, abala sa good governance, matinong pamamahala, hindi nagtatrapo, itong kalaban, bumubugbog ng trapo politics,” Medina said. (While our mayor is busy with good governance, avoiding trapo ways, the opponent is busy with trapo politics.)

"Eh kulang na lang, barilin ka nung kalaban mo eh. Kulang na lang, ganun ang gawin sa kanya, kung paano siya ino-operate sa ibaba," he added. (Your opponent would all but shoot you. That's about the only thing they haven't done to him, the way they operate against him on the ground.)

ON THE JOB. Pasig City Mayor Vico Sotto consults informal settlers in Barangay Santolan about a flood control project on August 9, 2019. Photo by JC Gotinga/Rappler

A doer, not a politician

Although Sotto has taken on the role of Pasig’s liberator and reformer, he has never taken a direct shot at the Eusebios.

In July, when he announced a massive inventory of the city government’s assets and supplies to account for the missing P1.4 billion flagged by the Commission on Audit, Sotto made sure to point out that it was not necessarily an indictment of the previous administration.

Meanwhile, his own administration is set back by the inventory because all procurements have been put on hold until it is finished, hopefully by the end of the year.

For instance, several computer stations at the Ugnayan office are offline because the moratorium covers internet service subscriptions.

It makes the work harder and slows down delivery, which the public may interpret as languor on Sotto’s part.

Because Sotto shuns the limelight, there is talk on social media that “wala siyang ginagawa (he is not doing anything),” especially because people compare him to Isko Moreno, Manila’s swashbuckling, media savvy new mayor. (READ: [OPINYON] Vico at Isko: Governance in the age of social media)

There is a constant stream of disinformation going around to discredit Sotto, who, every now and then, debunks them with a social media post crying “fake news.” So he knows his opponents are out to get him, and his tactic is to just keep working.

“Mayor Vico is not a politician. He’s a doer. We see that. Nakikita namin yung kilos niya, yung sipag niya. Kaya nga lang (We see his actions, his efforts. The thing is), politics will always play a role,” Salonga said.

Facebook and Twitter are good platforms, but they do not resonate at the grassroots,” where the former power is busy shoring up goodwill with every handshake and goody bag.

Besides, how many of Sotto's social media followers are actually Pasig voters?

“Naaalarma kami. Kung si Eusebio nadurog, naghirap, napanagot, we’re willing to wait kahit hanggang next election,” Salonga added. (We are alarmed. If Eusebio had been crushed, diminished, punished, we’re willing to wait until the next election [to do something aggressive].)

But the fact is the old guard is up and about, and “their tentacles of corruption, nasa city hall pa yung iba (some are still in city hall). And they’re still occupying good positions,” Salonga warned.

Although Sotto has taken a hardline stance against corruption, vowing to “never accept kickbacks” from government projects, and opening up public biddings to tougher scrutiny, Tambuli worries that the cunning, well-entrenched operators within city hall could easily circumvent the new rules.

Sotto, they say, believes in giving people second chances, as he did with the traffic enforcers. And that does endear him to people, especially the rank and file at city hall.

But Tambuli worries that his leniency might be taken advantage of. Instead, they want to see a purge of city hall in order to ensure the new administration’s survival, and to  truly weed out corruption. 

On September 25, Tambuli ng Pasig filed a graft case at the Office of the Ombudsman against Bobby and Maribel Eusebio, and several other city officials, for an allegedly anomalous “sister city” partnership with the Municipality of Pamplona, Camarines Sur. The group accused them of channeling at least P25 million pesos to fund Mrs. Eusebio’s failed attempt at running for Pamplona congresswoman.

Likewise, they want to see Sotto bare his fangs and take on his political opponents, even as he courts the public’s loyalty. At the very least, he could have the E insignia all over Pasig erased, just as he renamed the city’s scholarship program to be politically neutral.

If the changes he promised take too long to be felt, the tide might turn against him. Voters can be fickle and easily distracted, Tambuli warned.

So better make the adjustments now: be more aggressive. Amplify the message. Get ahead of the opponent.

ENTENG'S SON. Vico's father, Vic Sotto, is known for his sitcom-turned-movie icon character "Enteng Kabisote," an unlikely hero of epic, and comic, proportions. Photo from Pauleen Luna Sotto's Instagram account

The Son of Enteng

But the last thing Pasig needs is another Enteng or Bobby Eusebio, said Carmel Abao, Sotto's political science professor at the Ateneo de Manila University.

If, in order to secure his position, Sotto resorted to a negative campaign against his predecessors, as some of his supporters might urge him to do, the danger is he might become the very thing he is trying to fight.

That takes up so much energy and resource,” Abao said, but to really deliver services is also a way of countering the political opponent so, if anything, he should double his efforts to really show the people that theyve had enough of this Eusebio nonsense. It's been 27 years!

That means fighting the token handshakes and dole-outs with livelihood and health programs, education and scholarships, uninterrupted water and electricity – government services that give the people a sense of security that, hopefully, will keep them from becoming prey to patronage politics.

It's a tough call, but Sotto must rally Pasigueños around a vision of an improved city, something that goes beyond himself or any single politician. That means filling ordinary people in on his ideas and getting them to participate in turning those ideas into actual programs.

Sotto needs to go beyond social media to do this, and be genuinely rooted in Pasig society, Abao said.

After nearly 3 decades of ruling Pasig, the Eusebios will continue to be a force to contend with, along with the disinformation campaign to discredit Sotto and his administration.

Sotto has to recognize and face these contraints. He cannot not address these issues,” Abao added.

There will always be “constraints” to the governance agenda, as Sotto must now be well aware of. Politics is always about compromise. Just because he wants something doesnt mean he is going to get it,” said Abao. For example: hard-headed bureacrats who can maneuver to block reforms.

The trick, Abao said, is to give incentives for good governance, or reward good behavior. Sotto just needs to figure out how, given Pasigs nuances and idiosyncracies. Everyone can see Vico is new to this. You dont learn everything in just 100 days.

But, all things considered, Abao thinks Sotto is off to a good start.

Nagkonsehal siya. Nag-political science siya. Hindi siya pulpol. May laman siya eh,” the professor said of her former student, who just needs a little more room to experiment. (He was a councilor. He took political science. He is not a dud. He's got substance.)

His practice of politics is better than his rhetoric. I think his actions have been bolder than his words,” said Abao, recalling the instance when Sotto intervened at an employees’ strike against the beverage company Zagu. Sotto took the side of the workers and insisted on their rights, whereas most mayors would go easy on the company that brings revenue to the treasury.

Certainly, trying times lie ahead for the new administration, and the mayor must work to secure his reelection because 3 years will not be enough to institutionalize the reforms which, even now, are challenged by those who cling to the old regime.

Sotto must keep in mind that he has an opponent raring to get back in power, raising the stakes even higher. That said, the new mayor must also not let the next election turn into an obsession, Abao added.

For now, the honeymoon haze of Sotto’s surprise upset against the 27-year dynasty lingers. People jostle one another for a selfie with him. Bureaucrats want to be on his good side. The public keeps wanting to see or hear more of him.

That shirt, “Kay Enteng kami (We’re for Enteng),” was just a joke after all, a pun on the tension between the city's old and new leaders. On the back was printed the punchline: “Sa anak ni Enteng Kabisote (For the son of Enteng Kabisote),” referring to Vic Sotto’s iconic character in blockbuster movies: a bumbling nobody who married a fairy princess, forced to fight powerful villains and monsters to accomplish heroic feats. 

And the truth is, the people expect just as much from Vico Sotto, the Prince of Pasig. – Rappler.com

Viewing all 8777 articles
Browse latest View live