Quantcast
Channel: Newsbreak
Viewing all 8787 articles
Browse latest View live

FALSE: 'Photo' of dead, 'raped,' mutilated OFW in video thumbnail

$
0
0

Claim: The thumbnail image of a YouTube video shows a young man who was allegedly raped, killed, and mutilated.

The YouTube channel Paulo Sanchez uploaded the video on Friday, October 11, with the title, "OFW [overseas Filipino worker] sa Saudi Arabia, Pinatay, Tinanggalan pa ng Mata at Lamang-Loob pag katapos Gahasain." (OFW in Saudi Arabia was killed, mutilated, after being raped)

The preview image of the video shows two photos of a young man alongside a photo of a naked body, implying that the man was the one who was killed.

The channel Paulo Sanchez has 20 subscribers only, but the video already has had 113,203 views as of posting. It has a total of 864 interactions on Facebook, according to CrowdTangle, consisting of 584 reactions, 103 comments, and 177 shares.

Moreover, 28 unique URLs from 5 different websites that had the video and its title were posted on Facebook, according to the social media platform's fact checking tool Claim Check. Collectively, these have been shared at least 10,000 times.

The websites that had the claim were news24.philippine-win.info, gma-news.philippine-win.info, 247.balitangtv.info, media.balitangtv.info, and news.kanyeisinthelighthouse.com.

Rating: False

The facts: The news report in the video is real, but the man in the preview is still alive and was not the OFW who was killed. There is also no mention of rape in the original report.

The news report is by GMA News and was uploaded on April 9. They said that a 39-year-old OFW named Lemuel Lansangan was killed on December 8, 2018 and his body arrived in the Philippines with no eyes and internal organs.

However, GMA News did not show Lansangan's face in their video preview image and his photo in the report did not match the one used by the Paulo Sanchez channel.

A Google reverse image search shows that the man in the Paulo Sanchez thumbnail is actually an OFW and vlogger based in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

In a Facebook post dated October 12, the vlogger told his followers that he is still alive. "From October 10 up to now, I have received over 7,000 messages from fellow Filipinos worldwide, asking if I am dead?" he said. He further explained that the photos of him that were used in the video went viral in 2017 for his post about being an OFW and bringing home pasalubong (gifts).

Also, the original video news report and the corresponding text article that went with it did not say that Lansangan was raped. – Vernise L Tantuco/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.


IN NUMBERS: Vico Sotto’s first 100 days as Pasig mayor

$
0
0

NUMBERS TALK. Pasig City Mayor Vico Sotto highlighted achievements in health care, education, housing, social services, and good governance as he marked his first 100 days in office on October 8, 2019. Photo by Lisa Marie David/Rappler

MANILA, Philippines – Pasig Mayor Vico Sotto was “very happy” about the “relatively smooth” transition the city government went through during his first 100 days in office. His assumption to office was the first real change in administration in the city in almost 3 decades, and so he could be excused for expecting the transition to be pretty difficult.

“Considering that I replaced a 27-year family, the transition in Pasig has been very good,” Sotto told reporters after his State of the City Address on October 8.

And considering that Sotto put a dynasty out of power, and that he promised sweeping changes, constituents and observers alike have set their expectations high.

Here are what the Sotto administration in Pasig City has accomplished so far, in numbers:

Universal health care

P772.7 million2020 budget for free medicines and medical supplies, thrice the allocation for 2019, and 21% of the city’s entire budget for 2020
P470.5 millionadditional fund for medicines and medical supplies at health centers and hospitals for the rest of 2019
P152 millionallotted to renovate the city’s health centers
P36 millionto augment the subsidy of new PhilHealth members
11,000tricycle drivers and operators enrolled as PhilHealth members
0income target of the city’s public hospitals

Affordable, if not free, health care to all residents was one of Sotto’s main campaign promises, and, as mayor, he took steps to get ahead in implementing the national government’s Universal Health Care program.

Free medical services and medicines are a priority, so the city government decided to triple the health care budget for 2020 to P772.7 million, while it supplemented the budget for the rest of 2019 with P470.5 million.

The Pasig government also wants to bring those services closer to the residents of its 30 barangays, which means staffing and equipping barangay health centers.

In August, Sotto signed a partnership with the Rizal Medical Center, one of Pasig’s two public hospitals, to train doctors and and other medical professionals to provide primary health care at barangay health centers.

The city government allotted P152 million to renovate and equip those health centers.

The idea is to make health services at the barangays competent and consistent so that residents would no longer have to go all the way to the public hospitals, which end up swamped.

As for the public hospitals, the city government scrapped their income target. Rizal Medical Center and Pasig City General Hospital will no longer be required to turn in revenues to the city government, which would free them up to serve poor patients for minimal fees, if not free.

Sotto wants all Pasig residents to become members of the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth), in line with the Universal Health Care program.

Last week, the city government facilitated the enrollment of its roughly 11,000 tricycle drivers and operators as PhilHealth members, and Sotto said a total of 15,000 new members will be enlisted by 2020.

To fill in gaps in the subsidy from the national government, the Pasig government spent P36 million to cover the new memberships.

Education

P1.2 billion2020 budget for education
P1 billionspent on priority renovation and repairs of public schools
P420 millionscholarship fund for 2020
13,000scholars enrolled in the current term, 1,000 more than initial roster
16,000scholars to be enrolled in 2020

Sotto promised quality education for Pasig’s students, and that starts with proper schoolhouses and facilities. During his State of the City Address, Sotto said the city government had allotted P1 billion for “priority renovation and repairs” of public schools for the rest of 2019.

The city government has set the budget for education in 2020 at P1.2 billion, of which P420 million will go to scholarships.

After rationalizing the city government’s finances for the tail end of 2019, Sotto said they were able to reallocate funds to add some 1,000 scholars to the initial roster of about 12,000, bringing this year’s total to 13,000 – a new record for Pasig.

With the increased budget for 2020, Pasig expects to enroll a total of 16,000 scholars.

Beyond the numbers, Sotto said he wanted all young people in Pasig enrolled in school and able to participate in the city’s governance, especially in making policies that directly involve the youth.

For starters, he revamped the scholarship system so that scholars no longer had to earn “points” by attending government events with little relevance to their studies. Instead, scholars can earn their keep by doing community service as their class schedule allows.

Housing

P100 millioninitial fund for land acquisition for new socialized housing projects
P62 millionallotted for repairs of in-city housing projects
3%flat rate of penalties on delayed housing payments

Although it would be easy to evict informal settlers from Pasig and relocate them just anywhere, the new mayor’s promise was to always consult them before making any decision on their fates, and to relocate them within the city as much as possible.

On that note, the city government made an initial investment of P100 million in land acquisitions for new housing projects.

Meanwhile, P62 million was allocated for repairs on existing housing projects in Pasig.

Recently, Sotto signed an ordinance keeping penalties on delayed payments for socialized housing at a flat rate of 3% every month, as opposed to the previous practice of compounding the penalties for every month of delay, leaving the residents unable to keep up with their ballooning arrears.

It turns out, the compounded penalties had no basis in any law or ordinance.

Public services

400,000Pamaskong Handog or Christmas gift packs for households
11,200children at day care centers to receive weekly food rations
7,100malnourished schoolchildren to receive weekly food rations
P154 millionadditional “Aid to the Barangays” to augment their budgets
1Social Welfare Assistance Center

The yearly Pamaskong Handog or Christmas gift packs has become something of a gauge through which Pasig residents measure the competence of their city government. 

Sotto sorted out kinks in the system, starting with cleaning up the list of senior citizens eligible for the P3,000 Christmas cash gift to make sure they won’t have to queue up for hours in December as clerks scour the list for their names.

During his State of the City Address, Sotto announced that all households in Pasig would receive a Pamaskong Handog, to eliminate the practice of some local officials who hoard the gifts and selectively distribute them.

Every gift pack will be delivered straight to every door, Sotto added, so people wouldn’t have to line up at barangay centers waiting for officials to shake their hands or deliver speeches.

To make requesting social welfare assistance easier, the city government opened a Social Welfare Assistance Center that combines units in charge of persons with disability, senior citizens, and indigent residents. SWAC is, in effect, a “one-stop-shop” for residents seeking medical, financial, or material aid.

Meanwhile, Pasig’s 30 barangays will receive an additional P3 million to P5 million each to augment their funds, adding up to a total of P154 million in “Aid to the Barangays.”

Some 11,200 poor children entrusted to day care centers and 7,100 malnourished schoolchildren will receive weekly food rations for themselves and their families.

Governance 

P400 millionmissing assets and supplies accounted for out of P1.4 billion flagged by COA
379permanent job positions to be created in the bureaucracy
191former “job order” workers given “casual employee” status
649traffic enforcers given professional training towards regularization
190body cameras given to traffic enforcers to discourage bribery
83additional traffic enforcers hired to help ease traffic
340recognized civil society organizations
200accredited civil society organizations
1Ugnayan sa Pasig complaints desk and hotline
0ghost employees of the Pasig city government

One of Sotto’s first orders as mayor was a massive inventory of the city government’s assets and supplies after the Commission on Audit flagged P1.4 billion in missing inventories from the previous administration of Bobby Eusebio. 

The grueling hunt for missing items and the requisite halt on new procurements became a setback in the early days of his administration, Sotto admitted. During his public address on his 100th day, he said they had been able to account for P400 million of the missing inventories.

To help catch corrupt bureaucrats and to encourage citizens to report them, Sotto opened the Ugnayan sa Pasig (Touchpoint in Pasig) complaints desk and hotline on his 3rd week in office.

Ugnayan has since received hundreds of complaints and reports about fixers and laggard bureaucrats, as well as inefficiencies in government services.

Investigations are underway in a number of cases, and Sotto said those found guilty will be dealt with the “full force of the law.”

But Sotto acknowledged that many city hall workers are shortchanged, too, which explains why an undetermined number of them resort to indiscretions to make ends meet, or feel entitled to take it out on residents trying to avail themselves of government services.

The mayor announced that 191 workers on “job order” or short-term service contracts had been promoted to casual employees – still contractual but with a degree of security. Meanwhile, the city government will open 379 permanent job positions to give casual employees security of tenure.

Among city government workers who have started to benefit from the scheme are traffic enforcers. Sotto said 649 of them had undergone a training program to “professionalize” them and give them a new mindset. Those who shape up may become permanent employees within a year. Those who continue fleecing motorists will be fired and punished.

To keep them – and motorists – in line, the city government provided 190 body cameras to keep an eye on their actions while on duty. An additional 83 enforcers were hired to help sort out the city’s colossal traffic jams.

All city government workers will be receiving their pay through cash cards in order to eliminate the pilferage of funds meant for salaries.

With the reforms in the city’s bureaucracy, Sotto claimed that Pasig now has zero ghost employees.

To help citizens participate in running the city government, Sotto said they had accredited around 200 civil society organizations, and officially recognized some 340 others. These groups will be consulted regularly on policy issues.

Making a stand

While other city executives make it a point to be out and about for much of the day so that people could see them working, Sotto makes sure to spend just as much time in his office doing “actual work.”

It’s 50-50, he says. It’s about creating an efficient and effective bureaucratic system. A mayor who has to micromanage a city’s problems might not be doing such a great job.

So he might not be on livestream all day, but for Sotto it’s the numbers that should do the talking.

“This is about doing governance in the way that we think it should be done. This is a stand against patronage politics. This is a stand against corruption. This is a stand against closed government,” he said. – Rappler.com

Koko Pimentel, wife Kathryna expecting a baby

$
0
0

ANNIVERSARY. Senator Koko Pimentel and wife Kathryn Yu are celebrating their first wedding anniversary on October 18, 2019. File photo from Ron Munsayac

Good news from the Pimentel family: Senator Aquilino "Koko" Pimentel III and his wife Kathryna Yu will soon welcome a little one into their family.

Pimentel and Kathryna were married in October 18 last year, after being in a relationship for 3 years.

The former Senate president revealed the happy news in his first wedding anniversary message to his wife.

"I have known how beautiful you are, inside and out, even before we got married. But now, I have seen how great and wonderful you are, as a person, a wife, a mother to our two boys, and as a soon-to-be mother again to our third child," Pimentel said in his anniversary message to Yu.

Pimentel is a father to two boys, Aquilino Martin and Aquilino Justo, from his first marriage to Jewel May Lobaton. Pimentel and Lobaton officially separated in 2012; their marriage was annulled in January 2018. 

Yu heads PDP-Laban Cares, the humanitarian arm of the ruling party headed by Pimentel. Yu is a chef by profession and is currently managing Pimentel's law firm. – with reports from Camille Elemia/Rappler.com

FALSE: Photo of Japan's stormy skies 'during Typhoon Hagibis'

$
0
0

Claim: Facebook page Bob Ong Quotes posted an ominous photo of stormy skies over a beach and captioned it "#PrayForJapan."

Bob Ong Quotes posted the photo last Saturday, October 12, when Typhoon Hagibis claimed its first casualty in Chiba Prefecture, Japan, even before making landfall.

Facebook Claim Check, the social network's tool that identifies potentially dubious posts, flagged the post for fact checking.

Rappler spotted 3 similar posts of the photo using CrowdTangle. The earliest post was shared last Friday, October 11, in Facebook group Typhoon Hagupit Advisory & Update with the caption: "Typhoon Hagibis Photo taken October 11 at 4pm in Okinawa, Japan #prayforjapan #hagibis."

The combined Facebook engagements of these posts as of writing have reached over 4,100 shares, 20,100 reactions, and 900 comments.

Rating: FALSE

The facts: A reverse image search of the photo shared by Bob Ong Quotes shows that the original photo was taken in Rehoboth Beach in Delaware in the United States. The Washington Postpublished an article about it on August 26 this year.

The Washington Post explained that the photo shows a shelf cloud, which usually indicates a looming storm. "If you see a shelf cloud, it's time to dash. After all, they're the leading edge of strong to damaging wind gusts," wrote Matthew Cappucci of The Washington Post.

Though the photo was not taken in Japan, the country did suffer from the powerful Typhoon Hagibis. Nearly 80 people have been confirmed dead as of Thursday, October 17.

The typhoon also destroyed properties and triggered landslides and flooding. Look here for actual photos of Japan after the onslaught of Typhoon Hagibis. – Pauline Macaraeg/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.

Rappler Talk: Justice Carpio on his 18 years in the Supreme Court

$
0
0

Bookmark this page to catch the interview on Friday, October 18, at 11 am

MANILA, Philippines – Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio is set to retire on October 26 after 18 years in the Supreme Court (SC).

Appointed to the SC in 2001, Carpio is known as a staunch defender of the West Philippine Sea and an expert on the maritime dispute with China. He has openly challenged and rebutted several of the Duterte administration's policies and statements related to China and the West Philippine Sea.

On Friday, October 18, Rappler editor-at-large Marites Vitug talks to Carpio to discuss the past 18 years of his career, lessons learned, the future of the SC, and his unwavering advocacy of asserting the country's sovereign rights over the West Philippine Sea.

What needs to be done to uphold the rule of law in the Philippines? What reforms should the Court prioritize in the next few years?

Catch the interview on Friday, October 18, at 11 am! – Rappler.com

In Abby Binay's Makati, there are free cakes but no sugarcoating

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines – Six minutes past 9 one night in October, a bunch of teenagers decided to pick a fight with Abby Binay. Their weapon of choice? A group chat on Facebook, where they added the Makati mayor’s personal account and accused her of sexually gratifying a neophyte chief executive from a nearby city. They also claimed a much older, former mayor from the capital was her sugar daddy. The language was graphic and vulgar, but Abby was not shocked. 

Abby took a screenshot of the conversation and posted it online, covering the profile pictures of those in the chat group but making sure her attacker’s first name was free for all to see. 

“You add me. Insult me. Then block me. Tsk tsk tsk. This is a scary insight on how kids use social media and how it is possible that your kids have a different personality from what he/she lets you see,” said Abby. 

Unknown to many, the Makati mayor does not give a free pass to nasty commenters. Michael Camiña, Makati City Hall’s spokesperson and city legal officer, told Rappler that they would often trace where the student is studying then order the school administration to talk to the parents about proper social media etiquette. 

"In some cases, some of them get suspended, while others are merely reprimanded. I think it's a learning experience for them,” said Camiña. 

Abby, who is on her second term as Makati mayor, is no stranger to attacks online. She has earned the ire of students who message her directly about her refusal to suspend classes when other Metro Manila mayors are already announcing suspensions due to bad weather.  

Abby is not the type to simply follow the pack.

In 2017, during her first term, the city council laid down Makati’s own protocols on class suspensions in the absence of a typhoon warning signal. The process is long and tedious, which means Abby would often be one of the last mayors to announce the suspension – or, in some cases, she was the only mayor not to suspend classes at all. 

When sarcastic tweets about Makati students being “waterproof” trended, Abby responded by giving new raincoats and rain boots to every pre-school, elementary, and special education students in Makati. 

Mayor Abby Binay (center), her husband Makati 2nd District Representative Luis Campos, and Vice Mayor Monique Lagdameo distribute raincoats and rain boats to kindergarten students of Pembo Elementary School. Photo from the Makati City government

“People always have an issue with her, especially now during the rainy season, because she doesn’t always suspend classes. They would taunt her and say she’s the last mayor standing,” said Camiña. “But her decision turns out to be the right one in the end.”

Abby is not afraid to be unpopular. She wasn’t afraid to order the clearing of sidewalk obstructions in Makati long before President Rodrigo Duterte ordered Metro Manila mayors to do so.

She didn’t buckle when renegade councilors decided to ignore her veto message on the city’s proposed 2019 budget. The Department of Budget and Management later tagged this budget proposal as “inoperative,” raising red flags on the same parts Abby found problematic in the first place.

And when her own younger brother Junjun decided to challenge her reelection bid last May, Abby came out fighting. And she won, with a convincing victory – a lead of more than 80,000 votes over her sibling who had accused her of abandoning the legacy of their father, Jejomar Jojo Binay.

Abby, the scion of the Binays of Makati, is proving she is not out to just please anybody. 

No sugarcoating

Want to get Abby’s attention? Shoot her a message via any of the Makati City government’s social media accounts. Her team relays every complaint to the Viber group the mayor formed with her department heads. There’s always a barrage of notifications in the chat group even in the wee hours.

“I don’t know how she even falls asleep,” Camiña said with a laugh. “Early in the morning, she’s already sending messages or asking about things.”

Making Makati a smart city has been one of Abby’s main thrusts since she was first elected 4 years ago. She pushed to create the Makatizen app – named after the moniker she gave the city residents – to make it easier to report emergencies, like accidents and crimes, directly to city hall. Even tourists can access the app to get news about Makati.

Internet access is not a problem because the mayor pushed for the Makati Public Wi-Fi Project, a public-private partnership program that has so far connected 16 out of the 25 target barangays to the fiber optic network installed around the city.

Abby, the 42-year-old mayor who spent 9 years in Congress before leading the country’s richest city, wants the people in city hall to be as tech-savvy as she is. She often gives her marching orders through Viber or she gives a call to the department heads, who don’t have to go up the 21st floor of the city hall all the time just to get instructions from the mayor.

THE WONDER TWINS. Mayor Abby Binay checks out her phone as Vice Mayor Monique Lagdameo, Abby's longtime friend and ally, looks on. Photo from the Makati City government

Camiña came on board Abby’s team in 2016, when the latter defeated then-acting mayor Romulo “Kid” Peña in the polls. Camiña and Abby’s friendship dates back to their high school days, and he describes her as a hands-on leader who scrutinizes every detail.

“If you can see her desk in the morning, it's really full of so many documents. At the end of the day, she would have gone through all of these, read it, and assigned it properly to the official in charge,” said Camiña. “The next day, she would follow it up with you. And she knows what it is she's talking about.” 

A Rappler source who has worked with the Binay clan in the past years also says Abby is more blunt compared to her 3 relatives who were mayors before her: Abby's father Jejomar, her mother Elenita, and her sibling Junjun. People in city hall had to get used to this “no sugarcoating” mayor.

“She’s very direct. There’s no sugarcoating. If she needs something, you give it to her. If she has a question, you answer it,” said the source. “They’re not used to the style where the mayor is direct to the point. But that’s how she is!”

Not just her father’s daughter 

Abby’s attention to detail is a trait she shares with her father. Both are lawyers: Abby, a product of the Ateneo Law School; Jejomar, an Iskolar ng Bayan from the University of the Philippines College of Law. 

When Jejomar first became mayor in 1986, the patriarch’s focus was to restore investor confidence in the city after the end of the 21-year rule of the late dictator Ferdinand Marcos, while at the same time strengthening the social services in Makati. 

Decades later, Abby – as the 4th Binay to sit in city hall – has been building on the signature programs of her father since 2016. If Jojo Binay was all about social services and pressing flesh with the masses, Abby Binay was for “transparency, good governance, and strikta pero may puso (strict but one who has a heart).”

“The thing is, you have to evolve also because the needs of the people also evolve,” the Makati mayor told ANC's Headstart last April.

“I’ve focused more on kids. I focused more on the schools. I focused more on disaster and our health services. And, of course, my mass transport system. You have to address those things, how to provide more jobs. Because that’s what people ask anyway! They don’t ask, ‘Do I want you to become my godmother?’” she said matter-of-factly.  

The free raincoats and rain boots that Abby is giving out to students are an expansion of Project FREE or Free Relevant Excellent Education that her father launched in the city in 1995. From just free uniforms and school supplies, Abby expanded the program to also include free socks, anti-dengue kits, hygiene kits, and even sneakers – the viral Air Binay kicks. She has also promised to give free nutritious meals to public school students.

Senior citizens still get free cakes on their birthdays too – a practice started by her father when he was mayor. Abby continued the BLU card program, under which senior citizens get cash gifts, grocery items, maintenance medicine, movies, and birthday cakes from city hall. But she has also launched the Palliative and Hospice Care Program at the Ospital ng Makati (OsMak) for the elderly with serious and chronic illnesses. 

STILL LIKE HER FATHER. Mayor Abby Binay and Vice Mayor Monique Lagdameo personally hand a P100,000 check to Andresa Caparos, a centenarian living in Makati. Photo from the Makati City government

Plans are underway to put up 24/7 urgent care services in every barangay health center to provide immediate relief to patients who no longer need to go to the hospital emergency room. The city government will also build a public columbarium that would offer free cremation and inurnment services to the Makatizens.  

Abby is now pushing to improve the city’s disaster risk reduction and management (DRMM) efforts. Under her watch, the country’s first DRMM Academy was created at the University of Makati, where residents get formal training on basic first aid and life support skills. 

Public school students and families living within the 5-meter buffer zone of the West Valley Fault were given emergency go-bags and hard hats. The city has also installed 136 automatic external defibrillators as well as 307 CCTV cameras in public schools and in city hall, all of which are being monitored by the Makati Command Control and Communications Center.

But perhaps Abby’s most ambitious flagship project so far is the Makati Subway, a $3.5-billion joint venture deal between Infradev and the Makati City government.

The subway, which will have at least 10 stations linking different destinations across Makati, is eyed to not only improve mobility in the city but to also generate some 10,000 jobs for Makatizens, including seniors citizens who can still work.  

ONE STEP AHEAD. Makati Mayor Abby Binay smiles as she views the routes of the Makati Subway using a scale model. She is joined by Philippine Infradev President and CEO Antonio Tiu, City Administrator Claro Certeza and Makati 2nd District Representative Luis Campos. Photo from the Makati City government

Abby, her own woman

But Abby’s quest to stay at city hall wasn’t easy. The 2019 campaign left her emotionally bruised, drained, aching for some respite from the political battle she had to wage against her own family. She only had her father on her side. 

Former vice president Jejomar Binay was the only one in the family who said Abby “deserved to be reelected.” He was the only Binay in Abby’s sorties during the campaign. And he was the only person to sit beside Abby at the San Ildefonso Parish, when all other mayoral bets left their seats as Abby and Junjun’s rivalry spilled over the altar steps. With a defeated look in his face, the family patriarch had to see his warring children scream and point fingers at each other inside the halls of the cathedral.

Senator Nancy Binay, Jejomar’s eldest daughter, blamed the family feud for the surprising loss of her father in the congressional race in Makati’s first district. But the patriarch stuck it out with Abby even after his failed political comeback. When Abby was hailed among PeopleAsia Magazine’s “Women of Style and Substance” in September, Jejomar was there to applaud his daughter. 

“It was very crucial for her to still have her father by her side all throughout,” said Camiña.

"It served as her foundation too, because at least she knew that her father, who had established all of these things in Makati, believed in her, and that he was in fact there, fully supporting her ideas, her plans for the future of the city,” he added.

Jejomar would visit city hall every now and then. Rappler's source said the family patriarch has so far been impressed with Abby, who have been formulating changes Jejomar himself were not able to think of.

"He's very happy with what Abby is doing because he can see she is not neglecting the city. He can see the services are improving," said the source.

"He no longer offers advice on how to run the city these days because he feels he doesn't have much to offer to her anymore! He trusts that Abby can do it on her own. After just one year, he knew that Abby was on the right track."

Jojo Binay, the family patriarch, raises the hands of his daughter Abby Binay and his granddaughter Martina during Abby's proclamation rally on March 29, 2019. Photo by Rob Reyes/Rappler

That Abby is not the “KBL” politician like her father was an issue that she has long been criticized for. Unlike the family patriarch, who attended almost every kasal (wedding), binyag (baptism), and libing (funeral) when he was city mayor, Abby lessened her appearances at these gatherings.

It just wasn’t her.

“You have to also have a level of sincerity. We cannot copy our dad because our dad is different. My dad grew up different. So you can't just copy what he is because he wouldn’t have been mayor if circumstances were different,” Abby said in the ANC interview.

Jejomar Binay was the young boy who dreamt of becoming Philippine president as he fed his uncle’s pigs in Makati. Abby Binay grew up as the daughter of the longtime king of Makati who would later become the second most powerful man in the country.

So what did Abby do? She organized the Ugnayan at Lingkod Bayan Caravan, which goes around the barangays on Saturdays.

“Mayora sits in the front with all the other councilors and all the department heads, and whatever questions you want, you can ask right then and there,” said Alcine Yabut, one of the new faces in Abby’s city council.

“And she would give you an answer. Her memory is amazing! She’ll remember the letters you send her. She's really the one who reads them," the councilor shared to Rappler.

IN HER OWN WAY. Mayor Abby Binay gets to listen to Makatizens' complaints through her Ugnayan at Lingkod Bayan Caravan. Photo from the Makati City government

In one of these Q-and-A sessions, senior citizens asked Abby if the P100,000 cash gift they were supposed to receive when they turn 100 years old could be given in tranches instead. The city’s finances could handle it, so the mayor gave the go-signal for the city council to approve the ordinance in July. 

“So she’s not the traditional politician who wants to be seen so people would know this is her work. She would rather ensure that the system is working,” said Camiña.

“So the message is, 'Even if I'm not there, you know my presence is there because the system is working. I put the right people there. I put the right budget, the right funding, so everything is running well.'” 

Abby’s reputation as being mataray precedes her, but Yabut said she was surprised to discover the mayor was easy to talk to. Yabut said she and Abby would talk about the latest Netflix series they are both into during their free time. 

Alden Almario, another neophyte councilor, believes Abby finds the perfect balance between being a no-nonsense boss and a caring mentor. 

“Honestly, we idolize her,” said Almario. “She doesn’t side with anyone. If you’re wrong, you’re wrong. And she doesn’t give false hopes to people. If something cannot be done, she would tell you on the spot, ‘We can’t do what you’re asking.’” 

Abby’s unspoken burden

Though people in her inner circle will not admit it in public, it is crucial for Abby to lead Makati the way she is doing it now because she has to clean up the mess left behind not just by ally-turned-foe Peña, but also by the 3 Binays who were mayors before her: Jejomar Sr, Elenita, and Jejomar Jr or Junjun Binay have all been accused of corruption in the city. 

Both the Binay patriarch and his only son are facing cases due to the alleged irregularities in the construction of the Makati City Hall Parking Building and the Makati Science High School building during their terms. The Supreme Court recently affirmed the Ombudsman's indictment of Elenita for graft and malversation over the alleged anomalous purchase of hospital beds for OsMak in 2001. 

Even the free birthday cakes for Makati seniors were supposedly overpriced during the terms of Jejomar, Junjun, and even Peña

From the get-go, Abby told city hall officials she wanted transactions to be within the bounds of the law. No shortcuts, no favors. Another Binay cannot afford to be hauled off to court.

“She wants to follow the rule of law. Being a lawyer as well, she knows the limits and the boundaries of everything that she does or that the city does,” said Camiña. 

He said it was timely that in 2016, when Abby first became mayor, the new implementing rules and regulations (IRR) for the Government Procurement Reform Act was crafted. The mayor made sure city hall officials involved in the procurement process attended the seminar required under the IRR.

“Admittedly, we were very conscious of the procurement side of things because some of the issues that were raised before were rooted here. We didn’t want the same thing to happen again,” said Camiña. “So because of that, we became more conscious of the processes. Okay, this is step 1, 2, 3, 4. We cannot skip from 1 to 4 to 5 to 8.” 

Construction work on the 10-storey OsMak 2 – which first began under Junjun's term – remains on hold, as the Commission on Audit (COA) is still conducting its fraud audit on the allegedly anomalous bidding and payment processes done for the hospital.

“It was alleged during the Senate hearing that there were anomalies. If we would complete the reforms, what would happen to the fraud audit? How can they proceed?” said Camiña. 

And so when the Makati City government received in June another “unqualified or unmodified opinion” from COA for the second straight year, it was a source of pride for Abby. 

“I am deeply heartened by this good news from the Commission on Audit,” said Abby. “This second unmodified opinion shows that we have remained on course in espousing the principles of good governance, including transparency and accountability.”

A NEW BREED. Mayor Abby Binay addresses the city council during its inaugural session on July 3, 2019. Photo from the Makati City government

Does Abby ever feel the burden of being a Binay? Camiña does not give a straight answer.

“We don't point at anyone. We just do what we have to do. If there's something wrong, we find the best solution, then implement it. We don’t look for the person responsible and say, ‘It’s his fault.’ I don’t think she really ever did that throughout our 4 years already in office,” said Camiña. 

Abby has long been saying that she is more than just another Binay. She banks on her performance, she said, not her surname. But when Abby speaks, there’s always some homage to her father, and a hint of her desire to make Makati better.

“My most cherished dream,” Abby said in her speech during Makati's 349th Foundation Day in May, "is for every Makatizen to be proud of our city, to be able to say with pride and confidence that, yes,‘Ganito kami sa Makati (This is how we are in Makati).”

“Ganito kami sa Makati” was, of course, the campaign slogan that propelled her father from being long-time mayor to vice president of the Philippines. 

How are they in Makati? At the helm is a stickler for rules, a straight shooter, a no-nonsense executive. She's still a Binay – but a new breed at that. – Rappler.com

Header photo from Mayor Abby Binay's Facebook page

FALSE: ‘Sex video of Ateneo priest and college student'

$
0
0

Claim: A priest from Ateneo de Manila University and a college student were supposedly involved in a sex scandal. 

The website unlibuzzmaniac.com posted a video titled, “College Student at Pari ng Ateneo De Manila Viral ang S3X Video.” (Video of college student and priest in Ateneo de Manila went viral.)

The thumbnail image, which shows the faces of a priest and a supposed college girl, only appear when the post is shared on Facebook. A different image is shown in the preview of the video on the website.

The caption of the video reads: “Kitang kita sa video ang ginawa ng pari ng Ateneo sa isang estudyante.” (It's clearly seen in the video what an Ateneo priest did to a student). 

The claim was flagged by Claim Check, Facebook's tool that spots misleading content on its platform. It has been posted on the groups DDS Singapore Support Federalism, President Duterte Supporters Facebook, and President Rodrigo Duterte Group Official, which have a combined total of 58,700 members. 

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The priest and the college girl were not the subjects of an alleged sex video. The priest also denied his supposed involvement in the scandal.  

Using Amnesty International's video verification tool YouTube DataViewer, Rappler found similar online content that matched the thumbnail in sex video.Screenshot of Youtube DataViewer reverse image search

A reverse image search showed that the video in the claim was not that of a couple having sex.

The actual video shows a guy in a black shirt with his pants down to his ankles bending over and tucking his arms into knee-high boots.

The accused priest posted a message on his Facebook profile warning people about the spread of this false content. He said, "Please be aware of the FAKE NEWS (a supposed video with explicit content from a certain website) about me and a college coed that is being peddled by some unscrupulous trolls." 

The website unlibuzzmnaniac.com has spread posts with malicious content. Its claim about allegedly raped Ateneo and Far Eastern University (FEU) students was debunked as false in July. – Glenda Marie Castro/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.

FALSE: De Lima ‘rushed to hospital,’ wears neck brace

$
0
0

Claim: Philippine opposition Senator Leila de Lima was rushed to the hospital, as shown in what appears to be a screenshot of a live television news report.

Facebook page Tambayan Ni BERTO Page posted the photo on October 16, showing De Lima in a wheelchair and wearing a neck brace.

At the bottom of the image, the text read: “Breaking News: Senator De Lima, sinugod sa ospital (rushed to the hospital).” At the upper-left corner of the photo was a red text saying, “LIVE.” At the lower-left corner, it was timestamped 3:45 pm.

As of writing, the post got over 1,300 reactions, 83 shares, and 930 comments. A reader emailed Rappler the link to the post for fact checking.

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The photo was manipulated by superimposing Senator De Lima’s face over former president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s body.

Using reverse image search, we found that the original photo was taken by Rappler photographer Ben Nabong in October 2015, when Arroyo arrived at the St Luke’s Medical Center for a check-up.

De Lima’s camp also confirmed that the senator was not rushed to the hospital on October 16. “My health is in perfect shape and this edited photo was obviously made by paid trolls hell-bent to ruin, make fun of and discredit me,” said De Lima in a press release on October 18.

On February 24, 2017, De Lima was arrested over drug charges filed against her by the Department of Justice. She was granted a one-day medical furlough to undergo a CT scan at the Philippine Heart Center in March 2018.

“In fact, when I was granted a one-day medical furlough last year, I made sure to inform everyone about my condition and even reminded the public that there was nothing to worry about me. As a public servant, I have always been transparent,” the senator added. – Pauline Macaraeg/Rappler.com 

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time.


[PODCAST] Bakit kailangang magpabakuna?

$
0
0

(Subscribe to Rappler podcasts on iTunes and Spotify)

MANILA, Philippines – Inanunsyo ng Department of Health ang polio outbreak sa Pilipinas pagkaraan ng 19 taon na pagiging polio-free. 

Isang bata ang naiulat na may polio sa Lanao del Sur, ayon sa DOH noong Setyembre. Huling naitala ang isang kaso ng polio sa Pilipinas noong 1993 habang naideklara ang bansang polio-free noong 2000. 

Ang latest outbreak ay nangyari sa kalagitnaan ng sinasabing pagbaba ng mga nagpapabakuna o vaccine coverage sa Pilipinas.

Sa podcast na ito, pag-uusapan nila researcher-writer Jodesz Gavilan at health reporter Janelle Paris ang halaga ng pagbabakuna, kung paano napunta ang Pilipinas sa sitwasyong ito, at kung ano ang dapat gawin ng gobyerno at publiko. 

Paano na nga ba gumagana ang bakuna? Pakinggan sa podcast.

Ang Newsbreak: Beyond the Stories ay isang podcast series ng Rappler tungkol sa mahahalaga at malalaking isyu sa Pilipinas. – Rappler.com

Pakinggan ang iba pang episodes ng Newsbreak: Beyond the Stories:

LOOK: Duterte shows arm wound after motorcycle mishap

$
0
0

WOUND. President Duterte shows Trade Secretary Ramon Lopez a wound on his left arm. Malacañang photo

During his first public appearance since figuring in a motorcycle accident, President Rodrigo Duterte showed attendees of a business conference a wound on his arm.

In full view of media cameras, the President bared a wound on his arm during the 45th Philippine Business Conference and Expo at the Manila Hotel on Thursday night, October 17.

Duterte rolled up his barong sleeves to show Trade Secretary Ramon Lopez, seated beside him onstage, a red gash on his left arm, near his elbow.

"Yes, galing sa (from the) accident," Lopez told Rappler in a message.

"He (President Duterte) didn't discuss details of how he fell," he added.

MISHAP. President Duterte shows more people his wound. Malacañang photo

During the photo opportunity portion of the program, he again showed the same wound, this time to businessmen standing behind him as they all posed for a group shot.

Duterte had fallen off a motorcycle the night before after taking it for a ride inside the Presidential Security Group compound on Malacañang grounds.

Presidential Spokesman Salvador Panelo assured the public that Duterte suffered no major injury and only got "light bruises and slight scratches" on his elbow and knee. Senator Bong Go, Duterte's trusted aide, said the fall made the President's hip "a little sore."

On Thursday night, Duterte again got on a motorcycle – this time Go's scooter – but only tested it and did not take it for a ride, said the senator. – Rappler.com

Duterte dons 'air purifier' as protection from 'coughs and colds'

$
0
0

NO TO GERMS. The device around President Duterte's neck is described as an 'air purifier' to protect him from air-borne germs. Malacañang photo

As Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte hosted Indian President Ram Nath Kovind in Malacañang on Friday, October 18, media observed an unusual white gadget hanging from his neck.

He had apparently been wearing the same necklace during other events that week and the week before, such as the 42nd Cabinet Meeting on October 11, the military-police command conference on October 15, and the launch of a coal power plant on October 16.

The necklace is an "air purifier," said Presidential Spokesperson Salvador Panelo on Friday, October 18.

"That is an air purifier, so he will be protected from persons within his proximity who have coughs and colds," Panelo told media in a text message.

DEVICE. The air purifier device is more obviously seen during President Duterte's engagements with Indian President Ram Nath Kovind. RTVM screenshot

A Malacañang source told Rappler that the specific device around Duterte's neck is the AirTamer A310, described as a "personal rechargeable and portable air purifier."

It's supposed to eliminate germs, viruses, bacteria, odors, and allergens by emiting a "constant stream of healthy negative ions that force airborne pollutants away from your personal space," reads the description on Amazon.com.

This supposedly creates a 3-foot radius of "safer" air around the wearer's head.

The model Duterte is wearing is priced at $149.99 (roughly P7,799.48) on Amazon. 

The same source said even staff in Malacañang were given the same device.

Is the 74-year-old Duterte particularly vulnerable to coughs, colds, or germs in the air?

What we know is back in the day, Duterte was a heavy smoker, such that he eventually acquired Buerger's Disease, a rare condition involving the constriction of blood vessels in the arms and legs, blocking blood flow. (READ: LIST: 'Migraine everyday' and Duterte's other ailments)

He's often skipped events or gone on week-long absences due to health reasons not explained in detail by Malacañang. (READ: LIST: Duterte's skipped events, long absences)

Only two nights ago, Duterte had also gotten slightly injured in a motorcycle accident on Malacañang grounds. (READ: LOOK: Duterte shows arm wound after motorcycle mishap– Rappler.com

'The best chief justice we never had'

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines – On Friday, October 18, Antonio Carpio is again the acting chief justice of the Supreme Court, a post he has assumed so often that people call him the longest serving acting chief justice.

But the chief justice, he never was.

"(He is) the best chief justice we never had, I agree with that more than a thousand percent," Associate Justice Marvic Leonen said of Carpio on CNN Philippines' The Source.

After 18 years, Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio will retire from the Supreme Court on October 26. He is acting chief beginning Friday upon the retirement of Chief Justice Lucas Bersamin.

'Stick to your principles'

In the chief justice selection in April 2010, Carpio was deemed frontrunner being the most senior justice of the Court then. 

If ever, he would replace Reynato Puno who was retiring May 17 that year. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, president at the time, would appoint Puno's replacement.

But Carpio, the constitutionalist, believed that Arroyo should not be allowed to name the new chief justice because Section 15, Article VII of the Constitution prohibited appointments within two months of elections, or what are called midnight appointments. (In a ruling that year, the SC said midnight appointment ban does not cover the judiciary.)

So Carpio, sticking to principles, dropped himself out of that race.

He did this again 9 years later when Maria Lourdes Sereno was ousted as chief justice via a quo warranto mode, an unprecedented ruling that Carpio dissented against. This is because he believed the Constitution should be strictly followed in that impeachment is the only way to remove a justice of the Court.

"I have to be consistent with my position, that the quo warranto is not the proper way to remove a sitting member of the Court. So I don’t want to benefit from the decision to which I disagreed,” Carpio told ANC's Headstart in 2018.

Sticking to his principle is the main thing he learned in his 18 years in the Supreme Court, Carpio said.

"It taught me that you should stick to your principles and people will respect you for that," Carpio told Rappler in an interview on Friday.

The constitutionalist

Carpio said that there is nothing difficult with maintaining independence in the Court. Justices, he said, need only to do one thing: follow the Constitution and the law.

"The Constitution, as the fundamental law of the land, deserves the utmost respect and obedience of all the citizens of this nation," wrote Carpio in G.R No. 174153.

He continued: "No one can trivialize the Constitution by cavalierly amending or revising it in blatant violation of the clearly specified modes of amendment and revision laid down in the Constitution itself."

The year was 2006, and the case – called Lambino vs Comelec – would make a big mark not only on jurisprudence, but also on Carpio's career.

In that ponencia, Carpio ended the dream to extend Arroyo's term beyond the constitutional limit by rejecting the Arroyo-backed People's Initiative to change the form of government.

It was a loud "no" to Arroyo, the same president who appointed him to the High Court.

Rule of equity

"We are also a court of equity," Carpio said, explaining that in instances where the laws are inadequate, justices could be expected to interpret the Constitution in a way that the court could "dispense fairness."

"But only up to a certain point," he quickly made a caveat, "[because] if there is no law at all, we will just have to go to legislature to enact the law."

This was the principle at play in Carpio's ponencia that allowed the construction of Torre de Manila, a high-rise building that blocked the view of Jose Rizal's monument in Luneta, and which impassioned petitioners argued violated heritage and cultural rights.

A sensational case and one of the few that catapulted the Supreme Court out of its fortress in Padre Faura and to the national spotlight, Carpio was firm: Rizal may be photobombed, but no law makes that illegal.

"There is one fact that is crystal clear in this case. There is no law prohibiting the construction of the Torre de Manila due to its effect on the background 'view, vista, sightline, or setting' of the Rizal Monument," Carpio wrote.

'Do not play ball' 

Collegiality is a value that the current Supreme Court puts a high premium on now.

While Carpio agrees, he said he defines collegiality as just according respect to justices who may have a different opinion.

For him, it is never to strike deals and bargains, it is not about meeting halfway and compromises.

"If you play ball, then they know you can be persuaded, you can be swayed, better just to stick to a position which you deem is correct regardless, they will respect you for that, everybody will respect you for that," said Carpio. 

Bersamin said Carpio showed leadership that way.

"We may not have been on the same side of some issues, but you have never taken anything personally, you are the epitome of professionalism on the Court and it is hard for me to imagine how the deliberations in the Court will be like after your retirement," said Bersamin during his retirement ceremonies early October.

 

Legacy

Carpio will leave the Court with memorable concurring votes on decisions that impact fundamental rights.

On the issue of free speech, Carpio concurred in the decision that declared unconstitutional the government warnings against news organizations that published contents of the Hello Garci tape.

Carpio voted to shift the burden of proof to public officials who file libel complaints, saying that the “presumed malice rule is clearly repugnant to the Constitution.”

On the issue of religious freedom, Carpio voted to strike down provisions of the Reproductive Health (RH) Law that dealt with religious convictions. He also concurred in the decision that allowed a parish church to display tarpaulins of candidates with labels of either Team Patay or Team Buhay (Team Death or Team Life) depending on their stance on the RH Law.

On holding erring officials accountable, Carpio fiercely dissented against the acquittal of Arroyo, the bail grant of Juan Ponce Enrile, and the hero's burial of Ferdinand Marcos.

Just recently, he managed to turn his dissenting opinion into a ponencia that kept alive the plunder charge against former senator Jinggoy Estrada.

In his final days in the Supreme Court, Carpio came out with a ponencia siding with power consumers – he ordered the Energy Regulatory Commission (ERC) to review Meralco's unbundled rates with the aim of lowering electricity fees.

But it was short of the valedictory decision people had expected. Carpio is member-in-charge of the petitions that are seeking to declare Duterte's war on drugs unconstitutional.

With Carpio setting the tempo, the SC ordered the public release of war on drugs documents. Petitioner group Center for International Law (CenterLaw) later called these documents "rubbish," bolstering their case that the police operations – thousands of them bloody – were not documented, and therefore, illegal. 

And just before the en banc took a break, Carpio's last vote was a losing vote. He and Associate Justice Benjamin Caguioa wanted to dismiss Bongbong Marcos' electoral protest against Vice President Leni Robredo, but they were overruled.

"Members of the court will look up to someone who is unwavering in adherence to the rule of law, it will take time but the other members will see that this particular justice has been very consistent, and that's where you earn the respect of other justices, if you consistently defend the Constitution, consistent in applying the law, then you earn the respect of everybody," Carpio said.

"You have enough legacy to last the rest of your lifetime and beyond," Bersamin told Carpio.

Persevere

Carpio did not finish his law degree on time.

A frat brawl at the University of the Philippines (UP) delayed his graduation by a year, in 1975. Marcos declared martial law three years earlier, in 1972.

“It was useless to be a lawyer then,” Carpio reportedly said at the time, according to a Newsbreak profile of him.

But he would go on to establish the influential Carpio Villaraza, referred to in political and legal circles as "The Firm."

He would become presidential legal counsel to former president Fidel Ramos, and through links of The Firm, would score Arroyo's first Supreme Court appointment.

His life and career before the Supreme Court was a battle in itself, but Carpio said it was the High Court that taught him his biggest lesson – perseverance.

Carpio said that when he wrote the decision that upheld the constitutionality of the Baselines Law, he knew that the Philippines, if it tried hard enough, could fight for the West Philippine Sea against China in the legal arena.

"I've learned to pursue advocacies with more dedication, because if you want your advocacy to bear fruit, you have to press on and continue, despite all the odds," said Carpio.

This advocacy has, in more ways than one, also cost him the chief justiceship because he clashed with President Rodrigo Duterte on China policies.

"What is more important for the nation is that we preserve our sovereignty and sovereign rights because if we lose these, we lose that forever. That's far more important than any position," Carpio told CNN.

Bringing China to international court was a "moonshot," Carpio said.

But the Philippines scored that historic win over China in the international tribunal, and Carpio is showing no signs of backing down from either Duterte or the superpower country.

"I plan to continue my advocacy on the West Philippine Sea. That will be my main work," Carpio said.

And to the Court he's leaving behind, Carpio's parting words: "The court should remain independent, it should fiercely protect its independence, and the public should help the Court protect its independence." Rappler.com

Photo of Justice Antonio Carpio by LeAnne Jazul/Rappler

IN NUMBERS: How regions scored in the road clearing operations

$
0
0

CLEARED. Will cities and municipalities across the country maintain cleared public roads? Photo by Jire Carreon/Rappler

MANILA, Philippines – In their first 100 days in office, mayors across the country have been hard put to comply with the directive to clear primary and secondary roads in their areas of all obstructions.

The directive was given by the Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG), after President Rodrigo Duterte urged local government officials to reclaim public roads as a solution to traffic.

DILG Secretary Eduardo Año then gave mayors 60 days  to comply. If they failed to clear public roads without a valid a reason, they could be suspended for negligence and dereliction of duty.

Halfway through the 60-day period.  Metro Manila  was the top-performing region. The National Capital Region maintained its pace till the end with all the local government units (LGUs) complying with the directive.

Other regions were not as lucky though. After validating the efforts of all LGUs nationwide, the DILG is set to file show cause orders to 97 mayors for failing to clear their main thoroughfares.

How did each region score in the DILG's evaluations?

The DILG said that over 300 LGUs have yet to be evaluated. For one, the entire Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao has yet to be validated. Most of the LGUs in the Calabarzon area are still being validated as well.

High compliance indicates that 91-100% of roads were cleared.

In the National Capital Region, 12 out of 17 LGUs achieved a high compliance rate, while 4 scored a medium compliance rate. Only the city of Taguig managed a low compliance rate, which would be reevaluated since its efforts were acknowledged by the DILG.

While 29% of the LGUs in Western Visayas scored a high compliance rate, 53% of them scored a medium compliance rate. 

According to the DILG, a total of 328 mayors nationwide scored a high compliance rate.

 

A failing score means only 70% or lower percentage of roads were cleared. In Zamboanga Peninsula, 18 mayors are set to receive show-cause orders.

Efforts after the directive will now shift to maintaining its gains. The DILG has mandated LGUs to continue their road-clearing operations and these would be validated quarterly. – Rappler.com

Second-in-command no more, Joy Belmonte reshapes the Quezon City ideal

$
0
0

MANILA, Philippines ­– This is not like any of Quezon City Mayor Joy Belmonte’s speeches, which she usually delivers in barangay multi-purpose centers, small auditoriums, or on makeshift stages along any of the city’s many landmarks.

Clad in elegant Filipiniana outfit, she walks up the stage at city hall and addresses guests of honor, the city council, the officials of 142 barangays in the city, and residents watching through their social media accounts. She goes over a long list of gains in her first 100 days. She asks the city council to fund her vision in the next 3 years. 

This is her moment, giving her first State of the City Address. She is, at last, at the helm of the country’s biggest and most populated city, after 9 years of serving as second-in-command. 

Since her inauguration, Joy Belmonte has shown herself as a strong-willed local chief executive, conciously working out an administration that's neither weighed down nor influenced by whatever legacy the two mayors before her left behind: Herbert “Bistek” Bautista, who had endorsed her, and her father, Sonny Belmonte, who had supported Bautista before.

Establishing her own identity

In an Inquirer.net interview before her mayoral campaign, Belmonte said she had purposely stepped out of his shadow. “I tried my best to veer away from being the daughter of my father…. I made a deliberate effort to try to carve out my own identity, and to adopt advocacies that were never adopted by my father, and to have a management style different from his,” she said.

She intends to distinguish herself as well from Bautista, to whom she served as vice mayor for 9 years.

During her State of the City Address, she cited how her administration improved the implementation of the zoning ordinance, implying that it was lax during Bautista's term. 

Alam kong ayaw nyong pumalakpak, nandito si Mayor Herbert Bautista,” she said. She continued, addressing Bautista who was in the audience: “Mayor, yan lang naman ang totoo.” (I know you all don’t want to clap, because Mayor Herbert Bautista is here. Mayor, it’s only the truth.)

She has seen first-hand the shortcomings of the past administration, and she is now working to fill the gaps This, while city hall still bears Bautista’s name – in tarpaulins, television promotions, standees. A recently-released booklet still features a message from Belmonte as vice mayor.

In both her inauguration speech and her State of the City Address, Belmonte made it a point to acknowledge what she inherited from Bautista's administration – the good and the bad.

While Bautista touted the seemingly large amount of money he had left for the city, Belmonte was quick to clarify that most of that amount was actually lodged in long-term investments, leaving cash equivalent to a mere P516 per Quezon City resident.

While Belmonte thanked Bautista for the infrastructure projects he had put up, she also pointed out the how some of them were left unfinished, and how transactions at city hall remained sluggishness during his term even with the new facilities.

Residents of Quezon City would remember how Bautista and Belmonte had a rift during their last term together, barely speaking to each other.

Belmonte had said in the past that she suspected that their strained relationship was because of their different styles of governance.

“I take my job as the checks and balances of the city very seriously, and because he’s more traditional in his approach, tingin niya, dapat rubber-stamp ka lang, kasi ano ka eh, Vice ka lang, parang sumunod ka lang,” she said. (He thinks I should be a rubber-stamp because I'm just a vice mayor who should just follow without question.)

Vice Mayor Gian Sotto says Belmonte is “very non-traditional,” citing her practice of going down to the city’s 6 districts to oversee initiatives and build relationships, something he emulates.

NON-TRADITIONAL. Quezon City Mayor Joy Belmonte leads the demolition of a police precinct in Balintawak. Photo by Loreben Tuquero/Rappler

Barangay and Community Relations Department head Ricky Corpuz, who has been working with barangays for years, says Belmonte has been doing this since she was vice mayor: “Wala siya sa opisina, nasa labas siya.” (She’s not in her office, she’s always out [in the communities].)

When she speaks to her constituents, she is stern. She scolds them when necessary. But her tone is interlaced with concern and hope for a better city.

Recently, she warning illegal hog raisers in Barangay Payatas that they would face charges if they didnt follow African swine fever (ASF) containment protocol: Kayo po ay aming binibigyan ng babala ngayon, hindi dahil galit ako sa inyo, pero dahil gusto ko sa lalong madaling panahon, matulungan kayo at matulungan na lahat ng mga mamamayang lungsod namin.” (You are being warned, not because I'm angry at you, but because I want to help all Quezon City residents at the soonest possible time.)

In her first 100 days, she was able to make good on the promises she made at the beginning of her term, even as she was startled by unforeseen challenges, such as ASF and the national government’s directive of clearing obstructions from public roads in 60 days – the burden of which was heavier on Quezon City, which, with 166 square kilometers of land area, is the biggest in the National Capital Region. (IN NUMBERS: QC Mayor Joy Belmonte's first 100 days)

Smooth transition

IN GOOD HANDS. Ex-mayor Herbert Bautista showed up to Belmonte's proclamation rally, backing her mayoral campaign. Photo by Maria Tan

Whereas Bautista put a prime on infrastructure and urban development, building health centers, multi-purpose halls, sports facilities, and recreational parks, Belmonte is focusing most of her initiatives on the better services and their faster delivery.

Andrew Arevalo, one of the city’s 12 appointed urban planners, says Bautista and Belmonte’s respective priorities are complementary – Belmonte will fill in with services for the people the infrastructures that Bautista had put up.

It’s put in place, so kailangan na lang maramdaman ng tao kung ano yung mga institusyon na naitayo, malagyan naman ng serbisyong katapat,” Arevalo said. (The infrastructure is put in place, so we only need to provide appropriate services within or through these institutions for the people to utilize.)

Roel Cruz, another urban planner, says the two mayors are more mature than other politicians, who hold grudges and discontinue the projects of their predecessor.

Dahil ang mga politician ng Quezon City are more mature, lahat yan may continuity na. Hindi naman siya yung napuputol na dahil programa ni Bistek to, ayaw ni Joy,” he said. (Because Quezon City politicians are more mature, everything has continuity. Just because a program was initiated by Bistek does not mean Joy will discontinue it.)

Suwerte lang kami kasi yung mga nauupong mayor hindi mapaghiganti…. Kailangan to ng tao eh, ba’t mo ihihinto dahil ginawa nung kabila? Tuloy pa rin,” Arevalo added. (We’re lucky because our mayors are not vengeful. If the people need these programs, why would they be halted just because the past administration initiated them? Of course, they’ll be continued.)

Belmonte’s advocacy for better social services and good governance was apparent in her mayoral campaign, her inaugural speech, and everything that came afterwards. The current crop of councilors are aware that these have been her advocacies since she was vice mayor, who presided over them.

When she ran for mayor and kasama namin siya, that was her promise, and we were all aware of it…. So pag-start pa lang ng term niya, naggalawan na rin kami,” District 4 City Councilor Ivy Lagman explained. (We were with her when she ran for mayor. We were aware of her advocacies, so at the start of her term we already moved towards those ends.)

The city council has so far delivered. Financial assistance for fire victims, burial assistance, senior citizen assistance, aid for informal settler families, and healthcare have all been raised, expedited, or lobbied for increase. Their disbursement rates are also significantly quicker than the past administration, clearing backlog from as far as 2017.

Belmonte has the benefit of having a city council that agrees with her vision.

Iba talaga pag same page lahat eh,” Sotto said, speaking of the city council he presides. (It really makes a difference when you’re all on the same page.)

Lagman thinks it was a great deal that the city councilors were able to get to know Belmonte during her time as vice mayor.

We worked closely with her before, so meron siyang soft spot sa council eh, kasi galing siya doon.... Kami din, mahal na mahal namin siya, so talagang close coordination talaga kami, so we work as one,” she said. (We worked closely with her before, so she has a soft spot for the council because she also came from there… And we love her, too, so we really have close coordination and we work as one.)

When Belmonte asked the council for a P27-billion budget for 2020, with P2 billion alloted for medicines, Lagman said the city council considered it as “very welcome news.” The councilors feel the shortage of medicines firsthand when people come to them for solicitations.

The fact that nag-allot siya ng budget for it na malaki, meron nang ilalagay sa mga health center, sobrang nakakatuwa,” she said. (The fact that she alloted a huge amount that will go to health centers makes us very glad.)

Knowing Belmonte’s personality and priorities from the onset, Lagman says they were able to get behind her vision for the city even before she was elected as mayor. Now, they are more than willing to enact the policies needed to fulfill that vision.

Kung ano yung goals, kung ano yung gusto niyang mangyari, kung anong vision niya sa city, we’re all for it,” Lagman said. (Whatever her goals are, whatever she wants to achieve, whatever her vision for the city is, we’re all for it.)

Dreams of a cleaner city government

City hall is up for a intensive cleanup

“She’s really dead serious as far as services [are] concerned, as far as governance is concerned,” said Architect Pedro Rodriguez, head of the City Planning and Development Office.

Belmonte’s first executive order was to create an Internal Audit Service in line with her promise of accountability and transparency. Further, she seeks a more professional city workforce, composed of city employees who are promoted based on merits and not upon the recommendation of powerful backers.

Her intolerance for anything below these the standards of honest and efficient services shows when she does field visits. She filed a case against a private company that illegally charged vendors in a makeshift market every day. Corpuz said she spotted what he dubbed “organized crime,” pertaining to organizers who took advantage of illegal vendors.

On September 4, she ordered a probe into a local government official’s relative caught in the act of bribery in an entrapment operation. She threatened corrupt officials through a Facebook post.

To all of you who continue to be a disgrace to our city’s community of genuine public servants, I have news for you. Our people are smarter now. They are braver now. And they are willing to fight for what is right. Little do you know that your acts are now being videoed, your conversations recorded, and your names documented. These have been submitted to me. So don’t be surprised if one day, you receive an unexpected ‘regalo’ from me. Remember that KARMA IS A BITCH,” her post read.

POGO workers who got by on conditional permits issued by the past administration were told to submit their remaining requirements, or else face closure.

Belmonte wants not just good but decentralized governance, one that is accessible to all Quezon City residents living anywhere in the 166.20-square-kilometer city. She plans to build “mini city halls” in every district.

During her first 100 days, her city council also passed the landmark Freedom of Information ordinance, which will allow residents to look into the workings of city hall for themselves.

Their good governance dream is closer to reality, she said, thanking the proponents of the ordinance in her State of the City Address.

Once in QC, forever in QC

FOREVER IN QC. Mayor Joy Belmonte visits informal settler families in Balintawak. Photo from Quezon City Public Affairs Department

By and large, Belmonte plans to make her sprawling city smaller. In a forum, Belmonte said that she wants to make Quezon City a walkable place, with residential and business areas intermingled so that people won’t have to rely on taking private vehicles to work.

She also wants to change housing initiatives from the past administration to accommodate more informal settlers for in-city relocation.

One of the Bautista administration’s priorities was the development of the city’s socialized housing program, more commonly known as “Bistekville.” But Belmonte has something else in mind for informal settler families. She wants a township initiative, which she says is modeled after Singapore. She wants people who were born in Quezon City to grow old in Quezon City, and have the means to do so.

The Housing and Community Development and Resettlement Department (HCDRD) is completely onboard. They found that the Bistekville rowhouses took up too much space, and they were too costly for majority of the families to consider settling in.

Thus, they are looking into spaces where high-rise structures can be built, for a more affordable price. They are also studying ways for residents to avoid the tedious process of availing themselves of the PAG-IBIG Fund, and to rely on in-house financing instead.

However, Jojo Conejero and Joey dela Rosa from the HCDRD say that the challenge is to change the mindset of people toward accepting that they won’t have a land for themselves.

But Belmonte will not force residents to stay in the city. The point, Joey dela Rosa says, is that she’s giving them the option.

However, despite the city’s size, the city government is having a hard time with land acquisition, since it is competing with private developers. This will be one of the things the Belmonte administration will be reckoning with, if Belmonte's goal of in-city relocation will be fulfilled.

Beyond expectations

PLANNING AHEAD. Belmonte inspects vacant lots that could be potential public markets and parking facilities, in light of vendors and cars displaced by road clearing operations. 
Photo from Quezon City Public Affairs Department

Belmonte strives to do beyond what’s expected of her, and always plans a few steps ahead.

In the latest validation score by the DILG, Quezon City scored a medium-compliant score of 90. Belmonte thinks they deserve higher.

Dito sa kanyang first 100 days, we were able to clean the city dun sa mga kapabayaan ng mga nakaraang administrasyon,” Corpuz said, explaining that neglect and indifference led to the presence of so many obstructions. (In her first 100 days, we were able to clean up the neglect of the past administrations.)

More than clearing roads, she opened alternative ones to decongest traffic, dubbed Bayanihan sa Lansangan roads. She didn't stop clearing operations by the 60-day deadline, saying they would go on, targeting inner roads next.

She announced the presence of ASF in Quezon City before the Department of Agriculture did, immediately implementing containment protocol and cordoning off the suspected infected area. While the DA did not appreciate this move at first, they have given her command of containing the virus in the city, knowing she is fully capable of doing so.

In another case, she made sure that vendors displaced by the road clearing operations were now registered and relocated. She has also committed to remodeling and upgrading public markets to encourage vendors and customers to do business inside, not on the streets. And to top it off, she tapped the CPDD to study alternative sites for vending and recommend rerouting for jeepney and tricycle lines, to promote a better economy for small-time vendors.

But while Belmonte strives to make her mark, she has no grand illusions of being able to do it alone. In fulfilling her vision for the city, she knows she needs more than the city government’s resources.

Thus, she employs the help of the private sector, seeks the aid of national agencies, and even takes a page or two from other local government units, acknowledging that these best practices are for the betterment of her city.

Leading by example

SETTING THE STANDARD. Belmonte visits Barangay Holy Spirit, where they conducted self-demolishment in line with the road clearing directive. She thanked residents and lauded the barangay captain. Photo from Joy Belmonte's Facebook

Belmonte had spoken of her Viber group with Metro Manila mayors and their coordination regarding class suspensions, but, in truth, Belmonte is infinitely more active in her Viber group with all 142 barangay officials.

Corpuz says all of their concerns are acknowledged. Belmonte sees the message, responds with an affirmation or a follow-up question, then delegates accordingly.

But her work doesn’t end with virtual coordination and delegation. She still goes to the streets, talking to people, seeing for herself what still needs to be done, and implementing the city’s ordinances accordingly. Corpuz says she does this even when a lot of people will be angry, especially when business establishments and private organizations are crossing the law.

Government fixtures were demolished, and so was a village guardhouse, much to the dismay of the residents who belonged to the middle and upper classes.

Belmonte was unfazed. “Sabi ko, mag-move on na kayo kasi talaga naman outpost ninyo is in the wrong place and your real concern is security, so dun na tayo mag-focus sa security,” she had said, adding that they were still having dialogues with the residents. (I said, just move on because your outpost is in the wrong place and your real concern is security, so let’s focus on security.)

Gusto ni Mayor, set aside ang politics. Gawin yung tama para sa future generations,” Corpuz reiterated. (The mayor wants to set aside politics and just do what’s right for future generations.)

Belmonte is forward-thinking, and it shows in her plans for the city. These include efforts to sustain the gains of the road clearing operations, as well as traffic management plans for chaos that the simultaneous constructions of 4 Build, Build, Build projects of the national government is expected to bring to city streets.

The plans also include short-term efforts that still have significant impact, such as preemptive dredging of canals, which already spared the city from floods brought about by a recent typhoon.

“Kung ganun yung mayor mo na all over the city, tapos lahat ng problema sa city mo, lahat ng mga tao, mga organisasyon, mga problema nila hinaharap [at] binibigyan ng solusyo…sinong barangay official ang hindi mai-inspire, hindi mamo-motivate na gayahin ang leader nila?” Corpuz said.

(If you have a mayor who faces head-on the problems of the people and provides solutions, which barangay official wouldn’t be inspired and motivated to do the same?) – Rappler.com

Nene Pimentel: Courageous stalwart of democracy

$
0
0

FEDERALISM STALWART. Former Senate President Aquilino "Nene" Pimentel Jr. speaks during the 3rd Centennial lecture themed " Federalizing the Philippines" held at Recto room, Senate of the Philippines on August 4, 2016. Photo by Alex Nueva Espana/PRIB

MANILA, Philippines – Aquilino "Nene" Pimentel Jr, a stalwart of Philippine politics and democracy, has died on Sunday, October 20. He was 85 years old.

A courageous defender of freedom, Pimentel exhibited his integrity and patriotism in many pivotal moments in the country's history. He fought for the powerless and promoted the rule of law, and these fueled his staunch opposition to the Marcos dictatorship.

He was also known as the "Father of the Local Government Code" and later pushed for federalism as the Philippines' form of government, his ways of championing the autonomy of local governments and the power of the people.

Pimentel was a senator for 3 terms, from 1987 to 1992, then from 1998 to 2010. He was Senate President from November 2000 to June 2001.

His son and namesake, Aquilino "Koko" Pimentel III, followed in his father's footsteps. Koko became a Bar topnotcher lawyer, senator, and Senate President in his own right.

Early life

Nene's father is Aquilino Pimentel Sr, himself a lawyer in Cagayan de Oro City or CDO. His mother, Petra Quilinging, was a public school teacher from Batac, Ilocos Norte. In his book, Martial Law in the Philippines: My Story, Pimentel said his parents' "simple lives of honest toil helped charter the course of my own."

Pimentel Jr was born on December 11, 1933, in Claveria, Misamis Oriental, not far from Cagayan de Oro. He spent his entire student life at Ateneo de Cagayan (now Xavier University), and earned his law degree there in 1959. He passed the Bar the same year.

In April 1960, he married Lourdes “Bing” de la Llana, and they had 6 children, among them future senator Koko Pimentel and future Human Rights Commissioner Gwendolyn Pimentel Gana.

Nene fondly described Bing as “mother and father” to their children as he was always absent in the lives of his children growing up. She stood patient in her husband’s public duties and composed songs of love and loneliness.

Pimentel became the dean of Xavier's College of Law from 1962 to 1967. Around that time, he also co-organized a lawyers' group in CDO as their form of defense against what they called "oppressive judges."

Fighting Marcos

A few years later, he was elected to the 1971 Constitutional Convention (ConCon), representing CDO and Misamis Oriental. However, the mood at the convention for a new Philippine Constitution quickly changed when then-President Ferdinand Marcos declared Martial Law in September 1972.

Marcos committed "the ultimate sin," Pimentel said in his book. He added that Martial Law "clashed violently with my deeply-held belief… that it is democracy, not one-man rule, which enhances the value of human life and assures the equal protection of the rights of the people."

Fearing that the ConCon will be used to further Marcos' political agenda, Pimentel and other delegates gathered to become the opposition. Pimentel continued to be a thorn in Marcos' side, not fearing the dictator's fervent attempts to punish him.

He was arrested 4 times for his criticism of the dictatorship, which cooked up various charges to haul Pimentel to jail. But one way or another, with the law and his supporters on his side, he would not last long in detention.

During Pimentel's first detention in 1973 in Camp Crame, his wife composed a song called “Only a Moment,” which describes the pain of separation.

In 1978, he and his Lakas ng Bayan (Laban) party mates lost in their bids to become members of the Interim Batasang Pambansa. They protested what they called a "sham" election.

In 1980, he was elected mayor of Cagayan de Oro City, capturing the support of his kababayans and defeating the candidate of Marcos' Kilusang Bagong Lipunan party. The Marcos regime ousted him from office in 1981 for supposed "political turncoatism." But massive demonstrations in Pimentel's hometown – similar to the People Power revolution in 1986 – forced Marcos to reinstate him as mayor.

Around this time, in 1982, Pimentel and other politicians in Visayas and Mindanao formed the Partido Demokratiko Pilipino (PDP) party.

Opposition to the Marcoses reached fever pitch after the assassination of Benigno "Ninoy" Aquino Jr in August 1983. It was in this setting when Pimentel ran and won in 1984 as the assemblyman for CDO at the Regular Batasang Pambansa.

Once again, the dictatorship ousted Pimentel, this time based on cheating allegations during the polls. But the Supreme Court sided with Pimentel and reinstated him.

For the 1986 snap elections – shortly after PDP merged with the Laban party to form PDP-Laban – the opposition's pick for president, Corazon "Cory" Aquino, said Pimentel was her original pick as vice president, but she recounted that he "accepted it manfully" when Salvador Laurel officially became her running-mate following negotiations.

For his part, Pimentel said his main concern at the time was to help unify the opposition, and having Laurel as the VP bet "was good for the nation at that time."

OPPOSITION FIGURE. Then senator Aquilino Pimentel points to a questionable ballot box as counting is suspended 08 June 2004 in Manila, as a certificate of canvass in ballot box 21 is being questioned because it has a higher total vote counted than registerd voters, for the president and vice-president May 10 elections. Photo by Jay Directo/AFP

Post-People Power

After the 1986 People Power revolution which installed Aquino to the presidency, she enlisted Pimentel's help in rebuilding the country. He was appointed local government minister (later secretary), and then the government's chief peace negotiator with Muslim separatists in 1987.

He won his first Senate race in 1987, placing 20th with over 9 million votes.

It was at this time when Pimentel authored the Local Government Code, which decentralizes governance and provides for the autonomy of local government units. It was signed in October 1991.

Apart from the Local Government Code, Pimentel sponsored a number of laws during his first Senate stint. These include the Cooperative Code, the Philippine Sports Commission Act, and the People’s Small-Scale Mining Act, which mandates simple methods of mining and not with explosives.

He was also behind the law creating the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao in 1989.

Pimentel also authored and co-sponsored the Generic Drugs Act, which requires the use of generic terminology in supplying drugs, and ensures their adequate distribution. Generic names also promote drug safety by minimizing duplication.

In September 1991, he joined 11 senators in voting against the extension of US bases, ending the Americans' military presence in the Philippines. (Eight years later, Pimentel would reject the Visiting Forces Agreement with the United States, but he and 4 others were voted down by 18 senators in favor of the treaty's ratification.)

In 1992, Pimentel was tapped by then-Senate President Jovito Salonga to be his running-mate in the presidential elections. Pimentel ranked only 5th in the polls; Salonga, 6th. (READ: Nene Pimentel remembers 'Jovy Salonga, the man')

Pimentel ran for the Senate again in 1995, but placed only 15th. However, he held evidence showing he was cheated through a "dagdag-bawas" scheme or padding or shaving of votes.

His dogged determination for truth won him enough support to be elected to the Senate again in 1998, landing in 4th place with over 10 million votes. He became Senate President in November 2000.

'I resign'

His unquestionable integrity was on full display in January 2001, at the height of the impeachment of then-President Joseph Estrada.

Senators were deciding whether to open the 2nd envelope containing incriminating evidence against Estrada. Pimentel and 9 others voted to unveil its contents, but 11 senators outvoted them, opting to keep it closed.

In disgust, he abruptly announced his resignation as Senate President, and stepped down in June 2001, after the election of his replacement, Franklin Drilon. He became Senate minority leader in the next 12th Congress. (He had a short stint as majority floor leader from June to July 2002.)

Pimentel was reelected in 2004, attaining the third-highest number of votes among 48 candidates. He stayed on as the minority leader until the end of his term in 2010.

As chair of the Senate Blue Ribbon Committee, he recommended the prosecution of top government officials in previous administrations involved in the Expo Pilipino scam and in the fund misuse of the Retirement and Separation Benefits Systems of the Armed Forces.

The Blue Ribbon Committee under Pimentel’s eye also conducted investigations on Mayor Luis “Chavit” Singson’s alleged jueteng scandal in 2002.

In 2008, Pimentel authored a bill that introduced federalism as a possible shift in the Philippine governing system.

Post-politics

Pimentel retired from politics after serving his 3rd and final Senate term in June 2010.

That year, he told the Inquirer that his wife and children never complained or blamed him for his turbulent life. “As I look back on those early years, I often wonder how I survived the trials and tribulations of public life without Bing’s guiding hand and wise counsel. Without her, I don’t think my children and I would be where we are now.”

He remained a leading proponent for a federal system of government in the Philippines. He proposed the creation of 11 federal states with Metro Manila as the capital of the federal republic. The states would have a total of 81 senators.

His son Koko would back up the proposal in the 18th Congress.

Nene Pimentel was also a member of the Consultative Committee formed by President Rodrigo Duterte to propose amendments to the 1987 Constitution.– Rappler.com


Supreme Court chief justice: Of leaks and faux pas

$
0
0


Was it a leak or an attempt to preempt the President?

For the past few weeks, there had been wild speculations about who the next chief justice would be after the retirement of Lucas Bersamin from the High Court on Friday, October 18. In the past, when it came to appointments, seniority was the unspoken rule, but this had been broken so many times before.

Among the 3 who were short-listed for the top post of the Supreme Court (SC) – Diosdado Peralta, Estela Perlas Bernabe, and Andres Reyes Jr– it is Peralta, also a former Sandiganbayan presiding justice, who is the most senior. He is set to retire in March 2022, Bernabe in May 2022, and Reyes in May 2020. The appointing power, President Rodrigo Duterte, ends his term in June 2022.

The Manila Times published a story 3 days ago with the headline, “Peralta wins race for chief justice – sources.” It said that Peralta “appears to have won the race” and that Duterte was “set to appoint” him as successor to Bersamin. Notice how iffy the story sounded.

On Friday, however, our reporter Pia Ranada was told, “Still nothing.” Executive Secretary Salvador Medialdea and Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra told her so. Saturday, October 19, passed with no announcement from the Palace. As of late-Sunday afternoon, still nothing.

The Times seems to have taken down its story on Peralta as indicated by this message when the story is Googled. It instead links to a beta page of the Times:

TAKEN DOWN. The Manila Times takes down its story about the supposed appointment of Justice Diosdado Peralta as Chief Magistrate of the Supreme Court.

Even Wikipedia

The newspaper was not the only one that appeared to be the eager beaver. Someone, too, tinkered with Wikipedia, whose entry on Peralta was edited to this:

In this edited Wikipedia entry on Peralta, he was named Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines in the evening of October 17, a Thursday. By the following day, the entry was reverted to its original, and the edits undone. He was back to being “Associate Justice” from being “26th Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines.”

  


Quick lesson and takeaway from this incident involving Wikipedia? Never trust it as a primary source. You’ll always need to find corroborating information elsewhere.

Even former SC associate justice Adolf Azcuna excitedly posted on social media last Thursday, October 17, that Presidential Spokesman Salvador Panelo called up Peralta to tell him the good news. “Panelo called him (Peralta) up while he was lecturing in Philja Tagaytay to tell him that his appointment had just been signed. It will be released tomorrow since Bersamin is still CJ until midnight.” Philja is short for the Philippine Judicial Academy, of which Azcuna is chancellor.

Of course, he got it wrong. And the post has since been taken down. Call that kuryente in journalistic parlance.

What if...

Who does the President want? If Peralta is appointed, he would tie the hands of Duterte on the chief justice appointment all the way to 2022 since his term will end only 3 months before Duterte’s. But what if Peralta offers to step down after a year, opting for an early retirement, just so he gets appointed? Hmm, that’s always a possibility that's certainly worth watching. 

Bernabe is in a worse spot if Duterte wants more flexibility in appointing a chief justice because her term ends in May 2022 yet. This means he would be stuck with her till close to the end of his term. This is why speculation is rife that Associate Justice Andy Reyes would have a strong chance since he retires in about 7 months, or in May next year. But he is also the most junior among the 3 short-listed nominees.

Who does the President really want? Insiders whispered his preferred candidate is actually not among the 3 candidates, but someone more junior. Unfortunately or fortunately, the justice is not in a hurry to become CJ.

When he faced the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) last October 2, an emotional Peralta declared, “I deserve to be chief justice.” Tearful too, he told the JBC in a breaking voice: "I’m not a topnotcher, I'm not an honor student, because that's what they say – hindi naman daw ako topnotcher, hindi naman ako honor...but I think I was able to compensate with the work that I had done…. I think they are more than enough to compensate with what they say that I do not deserve [to be chief justice]."

Short of appealing to the JBC members, Peralta, who has been bypassed twice before, asked that his hard work all these years be considered so that "there is hope for an individual like me.” He apologized for being emotional, saying, “That's me, Your Honor, hindi ako (I'm not) arrogant. That's me."

But will the President listen to his plea? – Rappler.com

Vico Sotto would offer Bobby Eusebio a Christmas gift

$
0
0

NO TRAPO. Pasig City Mayor Vico Sotto delivers his State of the City Address at Plaza Bonifacio, Pasig City on October 8, 2019. Photo by Lisa Marie David/Rappler

Even with Vico Sotto as their new mayor, the people of Pasig have not heard the last of Bobby Eusebio, the former mayor whose family ruled the city for 27 years. The man is up and about and preparing for a comeback, Sotto’s supporters have warned him, but the young chief executive just wouldn’t lift a finger against his political opponent.

“That’s his right,” Sotto would say whenever he is asked about Eusebio still attending every other kasal, binyag, libing (wedding, christening, funeral) and fiesta in the city, as though he were still mayor.

It’s classic trapo (“traditional politician” or literally “dirt rag”) politics, and Sotto’s supporters from the civic group Tambuli ng Pasig (Clarion of Pasig) wish he was more perturbed by this, they told Rappler. The opponent would spare no trick from the trapo playbook to discredit the new mayor who, meanwhile, sticks to his ideals and would not fight back, at least not with any dirty trick.

His administration’s work will speak for itself, Sotto told Rappler in response. Confident that his administration will deliver what it promised, he wouldn’t waste time and resources on a “witch hunt” or “black ops” against Eusebio and his allies. (WATCH: Rappler Talk: 100 days on, Vico Sotto vows never to become 'trapo')

Sotto said he trusts that the people of Pasig know what’s good for them, and he wouldn’t have to worry about them switching back to Eusebio because they are bound to see the impact of his reforms in the coming months.

For one thing, they will certainly see a change this Christmas.

The old wiles of Pasig’s patronage politics had a way of seeping into even the seemingly most innocent of things. For instance: the city government’s Christmas presents. Pasig’s needier residents count on the yearly Pamaskong Handog to add some festivity to their meager holiday dinners. Naturally, the city’s politicos have been using it to earn the people’s loyalty.

“In the past, palakasan system talaga. 'Pag ‘love organization’ ng politiko, bibigyan lahat ng miyembro. 'Pagka asosasyon na hindi masyadong type, baka kalahati lang bigyan. 'Pagka kaaway, hindi bibigyan,” Sotto said.

(In the past, it was really a power contest. If it’s a politician’s ‘love organization,’ all members got one. If it’s an association they didn’t like, they’d maybe give to half the members. If it’s an opponent’s, they weren’t given any.)

Pasig’s senior citizens were each entitled to a Pamaskong Handog but it didn't mean they automatically received one either. Last December, many of them waited an entire afternoon at their barangay centers to receive their gift package, along with P3,000 in cash, because the distribution could not start until after a ceremony led by Eusebio, who had Pasig’s 30 barangays to grace with his presence.

Sotto did not want the lolos and lolas waiting in line anymore, so he ordered the city’s senior citizens’ affairs office to update their roster by going down to the barangays and personally enlisting every senior citizen. 

With the new mayor’s order to deflate bloated expenses and reallocate funds to more important items, the city government was able to free up enough money to prepare 400,000 Pamaskong Handog packages. (READ: 'Hahabulin, ipapakulong ko kayo': Vico Sotto warns corrupt Pasig bureaucrats)

That means this Christmas, every household in Pasig will receive a Pamaskong Handog delivered straight to their doorstep, Sotto said. No more long queues at the barangay center, no more waiting all afternoon for the mayor to deliver a speech.

Despite his supporters urging him to use the things at his disposal to gain the people’s loyalty, Sotto refuses to become the very thing he is trying to fight.

Kasi kung ako, bilang bagong mayor na pagbabago ‘yung sinusulong ko, gagawin ko rin yung mga traditional things na kinagagalit namin dati, bakit pa ‘ko tumakbo? So if I’m going to do all those things that they’re asking of me, baka maging traditional politician lang ako. Baka hindi ko masulong yung mga pagbabagong gusto namin gawin,” he told Rappler.

(If I, as a new mayor pushing for reforms, will resort to the traditional things that we were so angry about, then why did I have to run in the first place? So if I’m going to do all those things that they’re asking of me, I might end up being just another traditional politician. I might fail to push for the changes we wanted to make.)

And so he has decided to be faithful even with the little things, like the Pamaskong Handog.

“Hindi namin titingnan kung sino kakampi, kaibigan ko ba ‘yan o kalaban (We don’t look at whether they’re allies, whether they’re friend or foe), said Sotto. With him in charge, everyone gets a Christmas present from the city government.

Kahit si [former] Mayor Bobby Eusebio, bibigyan ko ng Pamaskong Handong kung gusto niya,” Sotto told Rappler, chuckling a bit.

(Even [former] Mayor Bobby Eusebio, I’ll give him a Christmas Gift if he wants one.) – Rappler.com

Inside Camp Crame, generals grumble over Gamboa’s revamp

$
0
0

QUESTIONED. PNP officer-in-charge Archie Gamboa during a Camp Crame press briefing. Photo by Adrian Portugal/Rappler

Without warning, the calls came on Sunday morning, October 20.

It was from the police's Directorate for Personnel and Records Management. You no longer hold your position, the officer said on the other line. You have a new post as part of a revamp.

This was how most ranking generals of the Philippine National Police (PNP) were informed that there was a massive reshuffling among its top ranks as ordered by their officer in charge Lieutenant General Archie Gamboa.

“Everyone was shocked,” said one general who spoke on condition of anonymity. And understandably so, as the police’s top brass generally give each other advance information before reassignment orders are implemented.

Another general said his reassignment is a “price” he had to pay for not gaining the favor of Gamboa.

On October 20, the PNP implemented its largest-ever reshuffling of officials – a rigodon round as they call it. But this shuffle began without them knowing, and now a handful of them are grumbling that they had to lose their post in Gamboa’s bid for the PNP to please the President and the public.

Gamboa has been on a campaign to regain the President and the public’s trust after their former chief Oscar Albayalde quit over drug involvement allegations. He is one of the 3 police officials recommended by Interior Secretary Eduardo Año to replace Albayalde.

In a command conference on October 15, President Rodrigo Duterte lashed out at the PNP’s top officials over Albayalde. A source present in the meeting said the President “did not know what to do with the police” and floated the idea that they be reshuffled.

Gamboa’s revamp has been internally questioned on two grounds:

  • First, his reassignment order shocked his colleagues as he implemented it as officer in charge. While Gamboa said that he gave the order with the authority of the National Police Commission, the degree or level of reshuffling was unprecedented even for an already-appointed police chief.
  • Second, Gamboa apparently decided on the movements by himself and did not consult with the PNP’s Senior Officers Placement and Promotion Board, a panel of senior officials that deliberates on assignments and promotions.

According to a source privy to Gamboa’s meetings, he convened a meeting only with personnel chief Major General Lyndon Cubos, comptrollership chief Major General Jovic Ramos, Chief of the Directorial Staff Guillermo Eleazar, and police-community relations chief Major General Benigno Durana.

Cubos and Ramos are classmates of Gamboa in the Philippine Military Academy (PMA) Sinagtala Class of 1986. Eleazar served as the representative of the PMA Hinirang Class of 1987, while Durana was the representative of the PMA Maringal Class of 1988.

They met last Friday, October 18, and Saturday, October 19, to deliberate on the placement of the officials. Personnel from Cubos’ office made the calls on Sunday morning, and on Sunday afternoon, the new officials sat together in a command conference in Camp Crame.

Officials who saw themselves demoted questioned Gamboa’s reassignment orders. One official, Brigadier General Marcelo Morales, supposedly openly challenged Gamboa’s reshuffling during the command conference, causing a scene in the meeting. From leading the prime Davao Region police regional director position, he was reassigned as the leader of the Police Security and Protection Group.

In a press briefing on Monday, October 21, Gamboa admitted that there were heated exchanges during their conference, saying that they “had a lot of discussions.”

“But when we went out after that meeting, they respect the decision of the OIC. Rest assured, what they all assured me is that we spoke there already, they let out their sentiments there, but after it, they respect the decision of the OIC, and we move forward,” Gamboa said.

A reporter then asked about the sentiments of the police’s top officials, given the reshuffle, which then prompted Gamboa to give a noticeably irked response.

“We cannot afford to have our own personal sentiments. It is very important in uniformed service to have full integrity, especially among its officers. We may discuss our sentiments but it should not go out, so I should not comment on it,” Gamboa said.

He added: “I hope it’s understood that we had spoken about it, and I said it was collective, but I decided, and that’s it.”

For Gamboa, the rotation of officials was only necessary as the officer in charge of an organization in crisis. Since the start of his administration, the PNP has been pampered by President Duterte. They were given salary increases. When the PNP faced overwhelming allegations of human rights abuses, Duterte stood as their strongest shield.

Now their chief defender is hurting, while the public remains dismayed.

“We admit that the recent controversy has shaken the institution at its core. Not only has it caused displeasure from our President but some doubts on our capability and resolve to serve and protect the people,” Gamboa said.

He added: “These are extraordinary times that call for extraordinary measures.” – Rappler.com

Is the drug war undermining the gains of government's anti-poverty programs?

$
0
0

First of 2 Parts

MANILA, Philippines – For the past 6 years, Irene, a domestic helper and mother of 5 who lives in a shantytown in Marikina, has been getting P1,500 a month from the government’s poverty reduction program known as 4Ps, short for the Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program.

Now in her mid-40s, Irene uses that money, a form of conditional cash transfer, to pay for the schooling, transport, and school supplies of her two children in high school because she and her husband, Gerry, a mason, barely made enough to keep the family housed and fed. (Irene and Gerry’s real names are not used in this story in order to protect the family’s safety).

Since its pilot in 2007, the 4Ps program, available to the poorest 20% of Filipinos, has covered some 4.4 million households with the intent of keeping their children healthy and in school. In the past decade, the government, with the help of foreign donors like the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank, has invested nearly P560 billion into the program. To date, some 12 million children have been able to go to school thanks to 4Ps. In 2015, the World Bank said it was one of the best targeted social safety net programs in the world.

Gerry and Irene had high hopes that 4Ps would allow their children to have better lives. Irene did her best to meet the conditions for staying in the program, such as making sure the children did not miss school. 

But on the evening of February 7, 2017, Gerry, who struggled for years to overcome his shabu habit, was killed by unknown assailants while he was eating at a neighborhood goto stall in Marikina City.

What happens when a government program to alleviate poverty collides with another government program to eliminate the drug trade? The travails of Gerry’s family show the fear, insecurity, and displacement faced by those who find themselves at the crossroads of two government initiatives.

For the past two years, we have been doing field and database research on 4Ps and the drug war.  Our  research shows that at least one in 5 victims of drug-related killings in Metro Manila in 2016 and 2017 were 4Ps beneficiaries.

We spent 18 months collecting the names and addresses of nearly 2,000 drug war casualties in the capital. We then showed our data to researchers at the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) National Capital Region office and asked them to match the names we collected with those of families who are in the department’s 4Ps database. The DSWD administers the 4Ps program.

To make sure the matches were correct, we validated them by visiting the homes of the victims’ families in 4 cities in Metro Manila and requesting families to show us their 4Ps household IDs.

We found that at least 333 out of 1,893 casualties that we had information on were 4Ps beneficiaries. We also found 12 cases where there were multiple drug war victims within the same family. 

This casualty list is incomplete. The police say they have killed an estimated 5,500 drug suspects in police operations since July 2016. As of March 2019, nearly 30,000 homicides are under investigation, a good number of which are drug related.

Gerry’s was one of them.

Mourning a husband

MOURNING. This mural depicts Gerry's wake, which was shunned by fearful neighbors even as plainclothes policemen kept watch outside. This was painted by street artists and volunteers in a hip neighborhood frequented by young people in Quezon City. Street art by Gerilya

Irene didn’t approve of Gerry’s shabu habit. The family had enough problems without his drug-user friends hanging around their shanty. One day, Irene finally put her foot down. Keep your shabu friends away or I will take the children and we will leave you, she said.

Four years ago, the couple separated. With her two teenage daughters, Irene moved to a house a few streets away. Still she and Gerry often checked on each other and Gerry continued to provide for his family. 

Gerry’s addiction was known to the neighbors and he feared being swept up in President Duterte’s anti-drug campaign, so he surrendered to the barangay during the first wave of Oplan TokHang in late 2016. Irene regrets the surrender. She suspects it put him on the radar of police and barangay officials, who were already closely monitoring the family’s progress as part of the 4P’s program. 

The barangay implements the 4Ps program. Its officials help select and monitor grantees, whose names, addresses, and family histories are recorded so the government can track their progress and check whether they meet the conditions for receiving aid. If children drop out of school, for example, families lose the monthly allowance they get for each child.  

Over the years, these officials have gotten to know the 4Ps grantees well. They know who are using or peddling shabu. When the Duterte administration implemented the drug campaign two years ago, the same barangay officials also became responsible for compiling drug watchlists that were often shared with the police. 

At Gerry’s wake, plainclothes policemen circled the area. Neighbors and friends who were there recognized the men and the guns bulging beneath their shirts. That spooked the visitors, and soon everyone kept away, afraid to be associated with Gerry and his family.

At the wake, barangay tanod and police investigators questioned Irene about Gerry’s drug use. “Ano’ng isasagot ko?she said,“Bakit pa? Hindi nila maibabalik yung asawa ko."

(How should I answer? What’s the point? My husband is dead and nothing will bring him back.) 

Picking up the pieces

AWAY. A mural showing Irene abandoning her home after Gerry’s killing is by street artist collective Gerilya, together with local residents, in a wall in an alley in Quezon City.

After Gerry’s death, Irene was forced to abandon her home. The police had tagged it a drug den, and she was afraid her family would be a target. She moved again, farther away. She was scared, she said, because it was not uncommon for police or bonnet-wearing assassins to return to the scene of a drug killing and target people they suspect to be associated with the dead.

Irene has many regrets. When Gerry surrendered, she wanted to send him to a rehabilitation program, but a barangay official advised against it. “Bakit mo ipapa-rehab kung kaya naman sa bahay? Magkakasamaan lang kayo ng loob (Why don’t you just do the rehab at home? He will be mad at you if you have him committed to a rehab center).

So Gerry was left to his own devices to beat his addiction. He was making progress, but it was slow. “Matagal yan na proseso, lalo na kung mag-isa (It takes a long time if you do it by yourself),” Irene says. 

But why did they kill him, she asks? Gerry was not a drug peddler. He had already surrendered. He was getting better. Did her neighbors rat him out? Were the barangay tanod and neighborhood policemen involved?

There is an overlap between TokHang victims and 4Ps beneficiaries, says Irene. Was the anti-poverty program’s information also being used to target drug suspects? 

Each month for the past 4 years, Irene says, she has been meeting with other 4Ps recipients in the barangay hall. The 4Ps program uses these monthly meetings to strengthen involvement in the antipoverty program. 

But when the drug war happened, the community was divided. Shabu users were ostracized, their children bullied. Many neighbors avoided being associated with those targeted by the police for fear they would be caught in the police’s dragnet as well.

Today, Irene is wary when she speaks with neighbors and friends. She no longer knows whom to trust.

Living in fear

MISTAKEN. This mural, painted by local residents and street artists in Quezon City, shows Irene shaking in anger when she was mistaken for her sister-in-law who is on the drug watchlist. Street art by Gerilya

Even when Gerry was alive and he was the family’s breadwinner, money was always tight. The money from 4Ps barely covered the children’s school and food costs.

After Gerry’s death, Irene was left alone to fend for two daughters aged 15 and 18 who are still studying while her older children have families of their own. Irene works odd jobs like babysitting her neighbor’s children, doing laundry, or watching over a store in the nearby wet market.

Irene’s daughters refused to go to school after schoolmates bullied them. Their father, their classmates said, was a shabu addict. Irene was quick to defend Gerry. “Maraming ganyan dito, pero hindi perwisyo ang papa 'nyo. Hindi siya nagnanakaw, hindi nanghihingi ng pera. (There are many addicts here but your papa was not like them, he never caused anyone any trouble. He never asked anyone for money.)” 

Instead of school, Irene enrolled her children in twice-a-week classes in the Alternative Learning System (ALS) but it would take time before their records in the 4Ps can be updated and they can be monitored for education compliance. But because they dropped out, they can no longer receive 4Ps grants for education until their attendance to ALS is monitored by the 4Ps program. 

Instead, Irene’s family receives P500 from the Family Development Program, P200 from the post-TRAIN Law Unconditional Cash Transfer, and P600  in rice subsidy per month. Irene wishes her children can return to a regular high school and not just because they can use the extra money. She worries they are not getting sufficient instruction, and without school friends, they would be missing the best years of their lives.

These days, Irene lives in fear. Once, a barangay councilor called out to her from across the street. “Linda!” she shouted.

Irene was frantic. She shouted and cursed, “That’s not me.” Linda is Gerry’s sister, who is of a similar height and build. Linda was a drug user who had since gone into hiding. Irene is afraid she would be mistaken for her sister-in-law. “

You never know who’s listening,” she says. She is nervous when she is with neighbors, suspicious of the people she passes on the street. For Irene and others like her, the trauma from the loss of their loved ones linger long after their deaths. 

Two years after Gerry was gunned down, Irene fears she will be killed in error. Who will care for her daughters when she is gone? – Rappler.com

(READ Part 2: War against drugs or war against poverty?)

This series is funded by the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism Story Project.

TOP PHOTO:  Mural illustrating Irene’s story was painted by street artists and residents in a community in Quezon City. Street art by Gerilya.

 

FALSE: Japanese government bans microwave ovens

$
0
0

Claim: The Japanese government is banning microwave ovens “before the end of this year” due to the potential harm of radio waves to humans.

A post by Facebook page Health & Wellness Online PH said the reason behind the ban was a research by University of Hiroshima scientists that showed radio waves “cause greater harm to the health of citizens over the last 20 years.”

The post also claimed that using microwave ovens is “more harmful than the American atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in Sept 1945,” and that food heated in a microwave oven has “very unhealthy vibrations and radiation, according to experts.”

The page posted this claim on October 17 and was flagged by Facebook Claim Check, the social network’s dashboard tool that identifies potentially dubious posts shared across the platform.

Rappler found 12 other Facebook pages and accounts that publicly posted the same claim from September to October 2019. These posts got over 600 shares, 300 reactions, and 70 comments as of writing.

Rating: FALSE

The facts: The information originally came from IA Panorama, a Russian satirical website. There is no official announcement made by the Japanese government that bans microwave ovens in Japan.

IA Panorama posted the satirical article on March 3, 2019. Titled “Japan will finally abandon microwave ovens by 2020,” the article contains the same information that was spread on Facebook. However, at the bottom of the article was a disclaimer saying: “Satirical edition ‘Panorama.’ All texts on this web resource are grotesque parodies of reality and are not real news.”

Using reverse image search, we also found that the photo used in the Russian satirical article, which was also carried by some of the Facebook posts, was a photo from Getty Images.

The claim is a rehashed one, but Philippine-based accounts and pages were sharing it again over the previous two months.

Moreover, a search of “microwave ovens” on the Japanese government’s official website yielded no mention of the supposed ban, as pointed out earlier by Agence France-Presse. This is also the case for the official website of Japan’s Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare.

In 2005, the World Health Organization (WHO) released an information sheet on electromagnetic fields and public health concerning microwave ovens. The organization clarified that the design of microwave ovens ensures that the microwaves are contained within the appliance.

“To dispel some misconceptions, it is important to realize that food cooked in a microwave oven does not become ‘radioactive.’ Nor does any microwave energy remain in the cavity or the food after the microwave oven is switched off. In this respect, microwaves act just like light; when the light bulb is turned off, no light remains,” WHO said. Pauline Macaraeg/Rappler.com

Keep us aware of suspicious Facebook pages, groups, accounts, websites, articles, or photos in your network by contacting us at factcheck@rappler.com. Let us battle disinformation one Fact Check at a time. 

Viewing all 8787 articles
Browse latest View live